Uber through the eyes of an occasional visitor

Do cab companies care to inform about the pricing model, to their drivers? Apparently it's all about making hay while the sun shines.

Here’s a quick anecdote about the puzzle that was the Uber business model in Bengaluru. I visited Bangalore — the city I am from — earlier this year. I’ve been used to driving my parents’ car around town while visiting; for the first time, though, the consensus opinion from friends and family was that I should Uber the entire time instead. I’m a fan of convenience, so I agreed.

It was pleasant enough: the cars were new, clean and shiny; prices were cheap when paid in USD; cars were abundant. Practically all the drivers were local Kannadigas who had quit jobs in the service industry to buy their own cars.

At this point, I discovered that Uber’s business model there was even more ruthless than I expected — enough so that I was worried for every driver who drove me.

Uber was clearly looking to corner the market; to do so, they weren’t paying drivers what they do in the rest of the world, i.e. the larger percentage of the fare the passenger actually paid. Instead, they were paying drivers an escalating amount based on the number of trips they completed in a day, irrespective of the actual length of each trip. For example, a driver got paid nothing for completing 10 trips; ₹1,000 if they hit 12 and stopped there; ₹2,000 if they hit 15; and something obscene like ₹5,000 if they hit 20 (capped around here).

What this meant was that a lot of cars were on the road all the time, all the drivers were working long hours, and all of them were easily making their car mortgage payments.

The nub, though, was that no driver actually seemed to be aware that this pricing model would change soon. Not one driver actually knew of Uber’s standard international pricing model, and Uber sure as hell hadn’t told them about it yet. Practically all of them had effectively mortgaged the cars I sat in; that led to interesting conversations about the economic model of their investments, and earnest attempts by me to convince them to pay off their car mortgages as soon as humanly possible, before the shit hit the fan.

It’s been six months since I visited. I wonder if the payment model has changed yet. If Uber has in fact cornered the market by now, and started paying drivers 70% of passenger payments for every trip (while also unilaterally cutting fare levels, like they always do), then it effectively leaves a lot of earnest folk struggling to pay off their primary asset.

At least I’ll get an easy ride.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Similar Story

BEST no longer: How contract buses are hampering services in Mumbai

Wet-leased buses, far outnumbering BEST’s own fleet now, are bogged down by multiple problems as contractors try to cut costs.

In Part 1 of this series, we discussed how BEST’s wet-leased buses — owned and operated by private contractors — are rapidly replacing its own fleet. In Part 2, we explore how this model is impacting the quality of bus services.Last December, nine people were killed and another 37 injured in an accident involving a wet-leased electric bus in Kurla. According to the police, the driver had not been adequately trained before being moved to an automatic electric bus from manual, geared buses. Under the wet-leasing model, introduced to cut BEST’s costs, a contractor owns and operates the bus, and…

Similar Story

Banking on contract buses, BEST to scrap three-quarters of its own fleet in a year

While BEST plans to reduce its fleet to 226 buses, the workers' union is against contracted buses known for their poor service quality

The Brihanmumbai Electric Supply and Transport Undertaking (BEST), considered Mumbai’s second-biggest public transport lifeline, is far from its glory days. The bus accident in Kurla last December that killed nine passengers has brought sharp scrutiny on its operations. The company is also battling losses and recurrent workers’ strikes, the latest one being a flash strike by drivers last week at Wadala depot. According to activists and the BEST Workers’ Union, the core problem is the wet-leasing model introduced in 2018, under which contractors own and operate buses on behalf of BEST. Since then, BEST has steeply reduced its own fleet,…