Rejoice Bengaluru, your ‘Big Ben’ is here!

The city's new 'sky-kissing' clock tower cost the exchequer all of Rs 90 lakh, but whose needs does it really address?

If you live within three km of South End circle, you have good news – you can throw away your wall clocks and wrist-watches, for the city administration has now put in place for you a fancy timekeeper, a 61 foot high ‘sky-kissing’, ambara chumbana clock tower at the traffic intersection that chimes out the hour, every hour.

With elections approaching, perhaps those sitting in decision-making kursis felt that just as the rural raitaru have been promised free electricity and other handouts, we the educated urban citizens too needed some goodies and gifts, so that we do not feel left out. And what better gift, than a showpiece clock tower, since we do not need fertilisers or subsidised pesticides or electricity to irrigate our fields?

Jayanagar clock tower. Pic: Anush Shetty

Costing all of Rs 90 lakh, this showpiece — the state’s tallest clock — is meant to make life sweeter for us. Visually and aurally. It not only chimes out the hours but even changes colour through the week — if it is yellow, it must be Thursday, so you can throw away your new calendars too.

Step a few metres to the south and north of this intersection, and you have rubble strewn all along the roads and pavements, thanks to the Metro line work that has been going on around South End for some years now, turning the once-green-and-pastoral-and-peaceful neigbourhood into one massive dust bowl. (There used to be so much open space and greenery around South End when I was a new bride, five decades ago, that it used to look desolate).

Take a poll today, and you will find that the incidence of respiratory ailments among residents here has shot up significantly over the last three years since the Metro construction began, but now a chiming public clock can take our minds off our asthma and coughs. Ninety lakhs is perhaps a small price to pay, for such public diversions, almost a son-e’lumiere, sound and light show, like they have in Paris and London.

Paris reminds me — remember the French queen Mary Antoinette, who said, when told that the janata were unhappy because they had no bread to eat, "Let ‘em eat cake" ? She was beheaded for her insensitivity. But that was in the bad old days of monarchy. We are a modern democracy, where governance is "by the people, for the people, of the people" as we all learned from our social studies textbooks in school.

Ah, the people — that reminds me again, where were the people for whom this swanky clock tower has been put up using taxpayers’ money? The Residents Welfare Associations (RWA) of the area were not invited to the inauguration ceremony on Saturday February 23, forget about their being consulted on the clock project before it was undertaken.

Getting them on board for deciding what they would want, could cause hassles, you see — RWAs have a way of raising uncomfortable questions, like "If you have Rs 90 lakhs to spend, why don’t you use it to improve the pavements in these blocks, repair the potholes, and remove rotting rubbish from the roadside and install garbage bins?"

These ‘concerned citizens’ do not understand the value and importance of ‘image’. A city that can boast of the tallest clock in the state acquires an image, people will come from all over to see and marvel over this structure that the state government has put up, even tourists will flock to see it after they have done the mandatory tours of Lalbagh and the Bull temple.

As for garbage and potholes, they are always there, why not help people take their minds off such dreary dimensions of their daily lives, by giving them something new, something fancy? Like cake, instead of bread.

As BJP leader Ananthakumar put it at the inaugural function, the tall clock tower is proof that we have "development 24X7" — and the hourly chimes will be a constant reminder of that fact (never mind if those chimes disturb the concentration of a child preparing for the forthcoming annual examinations, or the sleep of an exhausted senior citizen having a siesta.) And never mind if the 20 second conch sound that the clock makes hourly, is seen as a "nuisance" by some residents. Conch, you see, is part of our ancient rituals of Hindu prayers, and reviving our heritage and traditional customs is what development is all about, at least the way the ruling party sees it.

The clock also gives us something more to divert ourselves with – you can have fun placing bets about how long the chimes will work, how soon the ‘daily colours’ will stop functioning, when the first breakdown is likely to be. All this fun and diversion, for just Rs 90 lakhs. Good value for money, wouldn’t you say? Filling potholes with that amount, or providing garbage bins, doesn’t have the same glamour and diversionary value, right ?

I live within three km of South End. And I hate the sound of conches, somehow it reminds me of gloomy, sad observances; its cadences carry a dimension of desolation, perhaps because of a childhood association with a visit to a temple where a bull was being prepared for butchering, to the accompaniment of the blowing of conches. I don’t particularly look forward to the sound of the conch from this modern clock tower — except that mercifully, in the pervasive din that the traffic around South End raises, the sound of the conch doesn’t reach me indoors.

And as they tell me, at the police station and corporation offices, as a senior citizen I am "better off staying indoors." That’s Bengaluru for you, in the twenty first century…

Comments:

  1. Nanda Ramesh says:

    Good one. For me, the conch sounding chimes gives a feeling of impending funeral! Maybe for the trees which have escaped the axe so far, eh? 🙂

  2. Hanna Ciuba says:

    I like clocks, I think it should be in a variety of public places to remind us of the present time. In this case, however, not to mention the issued money, this design is just ugly (coarse, ungainly, grotesque). Price in relation to the appearance is astronomical! I’m sure that for the money you could make something really beautiful. If, indeed, it had to be created.
    I’m disappointed, but… I love this city. Sometimes it’s difficult love 😉

  3. Meera K says:

    It looks like a wall clock that somebody plonked on top of a mufussil water tank.

  4. M. Lakshminath says:

    These expenditures on landmarks in a city if maintained well for a long time will become heritage structures. These will be assets for generations to come.
    When late K. Hanumanthaiah CM built Vidhanasoudha there was a hue and cry but today every body appreciates its architectural beauty even a replica has come up in Belgaum.
    Though cost is an overriding factor such structures add beauty to every city, town , village, factory etc.

  5. Hanna Ciuba says:

    I agree – add beauty, but this clock is just simply ugly. It’s sad that this will scare future generations. Really, we can afford a lot more.

  6. Nanda Ramesh says:

    ‘@Hanna, afford is not the issue. 90L is plenty. I say we can do a lot better as far as aesthetic design is concerned. The whole structure is just ugly and Ms. Meera said it as well as anyone can. Mr. Lakshminath, Vidhanasoudha was built tastefully for that time and it has held its own until now. I doubt, this particular structure will have many fans 5-10yrs from now. There is no redeeming value that one can take away from it!

  7. Hanna Ciuba says:

    Vidhanasoudha is a beautiful, impressive work. Such places in Bangalore are very many, so I was unpleasantly surprised by the monster like this clock. Well, but it already exists. May be worth think about what to do to was nicer.

  8. prj says:

    Everyone here seems to think the clock was built for the public. We need to understand that these things are always built so the contractors and everybody else in the gravy train makes money.

  9. Vaidya R says:

    From the bottom up it does look like the clock comes as a surprise. Seems to have been designed by an ex-BWSSB engineer. 😛

    But then, we are seeing a lot more of such art around the city. Like this masterpiece:
    https://churumuri.files.wordpress.com/2012/04/120429kpn61.jpg

  10. Pramod Naik says:

    This the most we can expect from our pot-bellied, illiterate netas and “leaders.” – a clock? BBMP’s idea of an architectural marvel is the good old water tank and this is just a minor improvement over that ugly design. The “Shankha Naada” is to remind us of our BJP Hindutva roots, especially for those living in South Bangalore.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Similar Story

How Mumbaikars can register civic complaints and ensure BMC action

BMC's system to register civic complaints is good, but the Blue Ribbon Movement is trying to improve redressal for a better and cleaner Mumbai.

In early January, Dahisar resident Pankati noticed garbage being thrown behind one of the electric junction boxes in Kandarpada, her neighbourhood. It had accumulated over a few weeks. This was not a garbage collection point and it used to be clean before. She decided to raise a civic complaint on that garbage issue using the ‘MyBMC Assist’ WhatsApp Chatbot, which is run by the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC). Pankati, a volunteer with the Blue Ribbon Movement, found garbage being dumped behind an electric junction box in Khandarpada. Pic: Aniruddha Gaonkar After waiting for over a month, the garbage was still…

Similar Story

City Buzz: Delhi ranks 350th in global index | Heat wave grips north… and more

In other news: Heat-related illnesses claim lives; Urban women in salaried jobs at 6-yr low and Delhi issues first bus aggregator licence.

Delhi ranks 350 in global index; no Indian city in top 300 Oxford Economics’ new ‘Global Cities Index’ report ranks Delhi at 350, the highest among 91 Indian cities. This was the first edition of the index, released on 21st May by the global advisory firm, Oxford Economics, which is assessing metropolitan cities across 163 countries on five parameters - economics, human capital, quality of life, environment, and governance. The top three cities in the list are New York, London and San Jose. In the category of human capital, which “encompasses the collective knowledge and skills of a city’s population,” measured…