Open letter to the BBMP Commissioner on BBMP’s expenditure and efforts in waste management

Observations and suggestions on BBMP’s expenditure and efforts in waste management from citizen volunteers at the data jam.

At the recently held BBMP – Work Orders, Budgets and Processes Datajam, a group of citizen volunteers analysed the data available in the public domain. Here are their observations and suggestions on BBMP’s expenditure and efforts in waste management.

To:
Dr. Harishkumar,

Special Commissioner (SWM)

Dear Sir,

We are a group of citizen volunteers who would like to share our observations and suggestions on BBMP’s expenditure and efforts in waste management.

Solid waste management constitutes 14.7% of the BBMP budget (1643.72 crores). As part of the Shubra Bengaluru Project, BBMP has identified 1,555 Garbage Vulnerable Points (GVPs) also called as ‘black spots,’ in the city. Of these, 1,479 (95%) are categorised as ‘evening spots,’ and 76 perennial spots. To monitor these black spots, BBMP installed 2,415 CCTV cameras at an estimated cost of Rs. 22.32 crore. In 2018, BBMP has spent Rs. 20 crore to install more than 2,500 CCTV cameras for the same purpose and none of them are in a functioning state.

Using secondary data, we identified that segregation of waste was a major pressure point for solid waste management in the city. Our analysis showed that inner localities like Chickpet and Shivajinagar were doing poorly in waste segregation. However, this is based on 2017 data.

Of the BBMP work orders that were publicly available, only 1% of work orders were made for SWM and the expenditure was also uneven across the wards. (Note: This analysis is based on work order data available on the BBMP site. It is not complete or comprehensive.)

BBMP SWM work order analysis
Map of Spending on Waste Management on 198 wards (2018-2022). Map courtesy: Opencity.in

The team also found that Dry Waste Collection Centres (DWCC) were unevenly distributed across the city, with 23 of 198 wards having no DWCCs.

DWCC centres in Bengaluru
Map showing ward-wise number of dry waste collection centres (DWCC) in Bengaluru; 23 wards have no DWCC. Map courtesy: Opencity.in

Suggestions:

  1. The latest data on segregation needs to be made publicly available
  2. At least 50% to 55% of municipal solid waste is also a valuable resource, which can be recovered profitably using different technologies through following processing options
  3. Organic fraction of municipal solid waste contains biodegradable matter ranging from 30% to 55%, which can be profitably converted into useful products like compost (organic manure), methane gas (used for cooking, heating, lighting, production of energy) etc. through the following processes

About us:

We are volunteers who participated in a recent OpenCity data jam – civic solutions workshop. The datajam was organised by OpenCity, a civic tech project that helps make public data on cities accessible to all. Our goal is to enable citizens and civic groups to have a shared understanding of their city’s issues and use data as a basis for co-creating solutions. At the event on July 15th, we looked at BBMP work orders, budgets and processes.

More about the event can be found here.

Report compiled by Bhanu Sridharan

Also read:

Comments:

  1. Cholanda Muthanna Subbaiah says:

    Collection, analysis and delivery of data’s serve no purpose unless the civic authorities are made to implement it’s plans and programs based on data’s.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Similar Story

‘Ellam Plastic Mayam’: Chennai’s solid waste problem and how to fix it

Residents must reject single-use plastic and make a conscious effort to segregate waste at source, says an active citizen.

Plastic has been in use for about 120 years, initially invented in 1862 to replace elephant ivory and tortoise shells. The first synthetic plastic, made from cellulose nitrate, was a commercial success. Despite its usefulness, there is a dire need to restrict unnecessary plastic use. Certain types of plastic need to be eliminated altogether. Polyethylene bags, polyethylene terephthalate (PET) bottles, and polystyrene food containers are among the worst offenders. One million plastic bottles are sold worldwide every minute, while 500 billion single-use plastic bags are used every year, and this number is projected to increase. After a single use, many…

Similar Story

Extended Producer Responsibility: Gaps in the draft rules for packaging waste and sanitary products

The draft rules are a welcome measure, but they must address these key issues if they are to actualise the vision of a circular economy.

The Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change, Government of India, recently released the draft  Environment Protection (Extended Producer Responsibility for Packaging made from paper, glass and metal as well as sanitary products) Rules, 2024 for comments. The regulation uses a similar framework as the Plastic Waste Management Rules on EPR (5th amendment) 2022. These rules mandate that producers, importers, and brand owners (PIBOs), including online platforms/marketplaces and supermarkets/retail chain register on the centralised online portal, and fulfil their extended producer responsibility (EPR) towards recycling, recycled content and end of life disposal, meeting the targets set for each.  Prioritise action…