Why right processes matter in city planning

In well-planned cities, the government makes the plans and the builders respond to that with project proposals – to build residential communities, commercial facilities, and so on. In our cities, the builders and individual plot owners make their proposals first, and the city then scrambles to figure out how to plan the city around that.

The order in which we do things is itself wrong. Within this error, looking for solutions to ‘manage’ the way things are done is pointless. Which is why making the planning body for the city work – as per law – is important.

People sometimes ask, as in the case of proposal to build the steel flyover – it’s a steal flyover, actually – why some of us are insisting on the right planning processes to decide these things. Will not another set of ruinous people make sure that process is also compromised, they ask. After all, there are so many bodies that are not working well, despite appearing to follow due processes.

Yes and no. Certainly, it is possible for ruling parties to compromise any process, even a constitutional one. At the same time, the only practical way forward is through the right processes. Following them gives us hope that things can be done right, with increasing pressure from the public.

That’s how we got a planning body in place in the first place. State governments have never wanted any planning bodies for the city. Instead, they have preferred to make ad hoc announcements about projects. By insisting this should not be done, a number of people fought and made sure the government set up a statutory planning body. Now comes the next step – of ensuring that plans for the city emerge from this body, with due deliberation

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Similar Story

The good news: Bengaluru’s unified transport vision. The bad: BMLTA rules auto-approve Tunnel Road

The proposed rules for the Bengaluru Metropolitan Land Transport Authority let major projects like the Tunnel Road through without a formal review.

The Karnataka government has notified the draft Bengaluru Metropolitan Land Transport Authority (BMLTA) rules — over three years after the BMLTA Act came into being — and has invited suggestions/objections by February 2nd, 2026.   The BMLTA was meant to be a unified transport body to regulate, monitor, develop and plan urban mobility in Bengaluru. The government had failed to constitute the Authority within the statutory timeline of six months. Now, the much-delayed draft rules propose to strip away all forms of transparency and accountability! One controversial clause (Rule 24) proposes to grant deemed approval to projects initiated between 2022…

Similar Story

Exclusions and evictions: Mumbai Pardhi community’s struggle for shelter and dignity

In Borivali’s Chikuwadi, BMC demolitions left Pardhi families homeless and harassed. They demand housing and basic facilities.

Over a fire of burning newspaper and cardboard, Madhuban Pawar, in her mid-60s, sits on the cold stone floor brewing tea. It is 11 pm, and her husband waits beside her for their only meal of the day: a single glucose biscuit and a glass of tea. In the wake of the December 2, 2025, demolition drive in Mumbai's Borivali, a lone cooking utensil is all the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC) left her with. Madhuban, like many from Borivali's Chikuwadi, has inhabited the slums for over 20 years. "I work as a sanitation worker. During monsoons, our job is to…