Many Chennai councillors unaware of Area Sabhas and Ward Committees

How many Chennai councillors know about Ward Committees and Area Sabhas? Will they bat for greater public participation? A survey finds out.

A collective of people’s movements and citizens have been working to strengthen local governance in Tamil Nadu. Voice of People, a non-partisan, voluntary organisation based in Chennai, is part of the collective looking to unlock participatory democracy in local governance through functional Area Sabhas and Ward Committees.

The above demand can become a reality in Tamil Nadu through the implementation of the Tamil Nadu Municipal (Amendments) Act 2010 (ACT No. 35). As a remarkable step forward in the way of urban local governance in Tamil Nadu, the State Government notified the Rules of the said Act on June 24 2022, thereby technically breathing life into platforms which till now only existed on paper.

However, the Rules notified after all these years lack so blatantly in the constitutional spirit of devolution of power and enablement of people’s participation in urban local governance. The Tamil Nadu Municipal Administration Department has failed to conduct public consultations on the Draft Rules before its notification, despite repeated pleas by the civil society collective.

Survey among Chennai councillors

Under these circumstances, Voice of People conducted a telephonic survey with the elected councillors of the Greater Chennai Corporation (GCC) on August 5, 6, 8 and 9. The aim of the survey was to assess their awareness and understanding of Area Sabhas and Ward Committees and to gather their thoughts about these platforms and the Rules that have been notified.

The survey was conducted as part of a larger campaign to raise various points including that the Rules notified need amending; the Government must consult the public before the implementation of the Rules and most importantly the Government should make a strong effort to take these platforms to the people and their elected representatives.

All but 45 of the 191 councillors who were reached out to for the survey attended the calls. Of those who attended the calls, around 110 of them spent time listening to the questions and engaging in the discussion in a courteous and attentive manner. Many councillors even opted to return calls made to them and to engage in the survey willingly.

Response rate of Chennai councillors
Response rate of Chennai councillors. Pic: Voice of People

At the same time, a few councillors refused to participate stating that they won’t answer surveys via phone. One of the responses received was also that as the councillor was from the same zone as the Chief Minister, they could not respond to the request without taking permission from the party.

Read more: Area Sabhas and Ward Committees: Power to the people or power with the officials?

Awareness of Area Sabhas and Ward Committees among Chennai councillors

The gap in knowledge among Chennai’s councillors about these democratic platforms paints a woeful picture. Almost 75% of the councillors surveyed were not aware of the concept of ‘Area Sabhas’. Though more of them said they knew about ‘Ward Committees’, they meant the meetings being conducted at zonal levels with the ward councillors as members.

Chennai councillor awareness
Awareness of Area Sabhas and Ward Committees. Pic: Voice of People

The councillors were not aware of Ward Committees as prescribed in the 2010 Act. When the councillors were briefed about these platforms by drawing parallels with Grama Sabhas in rural local bodies, many of them expressed interest in learning more and asked further questions about their composition, functions and area delimitation.

Those councillors who knew about these platforms said that they had read about them in print and online media. Very few mentioned that they had heard about them in one of the initial meetings conducted at the Ripon building. Unfortunately, none of them had an answer for when these platforms will be implemented.

Connecting with the constituents

Discussions during the survey shed light on how councillors networked with their constituents and addressed civic issues in their wards in the absence of these platforms.

A few councillors said that they had started conducting meetings at street and neighbourhood levels in their wards. Most of them stated that having platforms such as Area Sabhas and Ward Committees which bring the councillors, officials from various government departments and the people to a common location to reach a consensus on various issues would help them work more efficiently.

Very few councillors had reservations about the residents gathering in Area Sabhas and Ward Committees, discussing and arriving at a consensus. All of them said that when they received the instructions and guidelines from the Government, they would readily start conducting these meetings in their wards.

The survey demonstrates the willingness among councillors to kickstart the process of devolution, leaving the ball in the court of the State Government.

On the Rules notified by Tamil Nadu Government

Of the councillors who responded to the survey, 89% did not know about the notification of the Rules by the State Government.

knowledge of rules notified
Many councillors were unaware of rules having been notified. Pic: Voice of People

Despite six weeks having passed since the Rules were notified, it is clear that little has been done to sensitise the elected representatives on the matter. The lack of awareness among councillors raises questions about whether the Rules have a clear intent and vision behind them.

Read more: Constant vigilance needed for effective local governance in Chennai

Will Chennai councillors speak for amendments and public consultation?

It is only fair for the councillors to want to read and understand the Rules first, before raising amendments. The response of 72% of the councillors surveyed on their willingness to call for amendments reflected the same.

While 19% of the councillors said they would speak affirmatively for public consultations and amendments in the upcoming council and zonal meetings, around 8% said they would simply go by the decision of their party leadership.

public consultation and participation
Chennai councillors on public participation. Pic: Voice of People

Many of the councillors surveyed were open to in-person meetings to discuss the Rules and the gaps and to further their understanding of the subject. Most of them requested a copy of the notified Rules.

When the reason for the demand for amendments to the notified Rules was raised, including the concentration of power with the officials, many councillors shared the difficulties they encounter in their work due to non-cooperation from various officials.

The way forward

The survey clearly highlights the huge gaps in State Government’s priorities and action plans in reforming local governance and increasing public participation.

Here is what the State Government can do to course correct on the issue.

  • The Government must immediately prioritise the need to bring all the elected councillors up-to-speed on the composition, functions and powers of Area Sabhas and Ward Committees as the legally mandated people-participatory platforms in the urban local bodies.
  • A dedicated Institution for Local Governance similar to KILA (Kerala Institute for Local Administration) must be established to aid in research, address the gaps, and provide training and capacity-building to the elected representatives at various levels. This will empower and enable the elected representatives to function effectively and perform their duties.
  • The Government should craft a creative campaign with wide reach, spreading the message about these platforms in all possible ways, so the people understand the vital importance of their direct participation in the local governance

Also read:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Similar Story

City Buzz: Delhi’s water crisis, heatwave | NEET exam again for 1,563 … and more

In other news: Property prices spike in Tier-2 cities, 10 million urban houses under PMAY in 5 years and menstrual hygiene rules for schools.

Battling Delhi's water crisis amid heatwave The Delhi High Court on June 12 directed Haryana to reply to a contempt plea over its non-compliance of the court’s earlier order regarding water supply to Delhi. But the Haryana government on June 12 had told the Supreme Court that no excess water was released by Himachal Pradesh to send to Delhi. Meanwhile, the Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) government on June 11 formed “quick response teams” to manage main water distribution networks and prevent leakages, according to Water and Revenue Minister Atishi. Additional district magistrates (ADMs) and sub-divisional magistrates (SDMs) were deployed to…

Similar Story

Councillor Talk: Menaga Shankar of Ward 197 promises access to education and government services

Menaga Shankar, Councillor of Ward 197 has a vision of improving the standards of corporation schools and bringing e-Sevai centres to her ward.

Menaga Shankar was born, brought up and married in Uthandi, now a part of Ward 197. She contested on an AIADMK ticket and was elected as a first-time councillor from the same ward. A political science student in college, she entered politics to bring good educational infrastructure to the people. She says she is particularly invested in the education of girl children. Ward 197 has upmarket localities with posh bungalows along the coast, while on the other hand, it is also home to marginalised communities who depend on fishing and farming for their livelihood. The ward’s boundaries begin in Akkarai…