Affordable housing, not livable houses

Smart spaces or compartment houses? The city of Bengaluru will soon start overflowing with these architectural disasters.

“Affordable homes with Smart Spaces and Community living” — so goes oft seen copy in real estate advertisements and marketing brochures.

Pic courtesy: Wikimedia Commons, Amol Gaitonde.

First, let us clear the misconception that affordable homes are related to the lower income group. The word affordability has been misused by many in residential real estate market today.

Affordability in its true sense means what is affordable for people living in that locality and it is very contextual. A two crore 2 BHK in Lavelle road is affordable for people who are living in Lavelle road and the same two crore 2 BHK is unaffordable for people living in Sarjapur road. Likewise a 50 lakh 2 BHK is affordable for people living in Marathahalli but a 50 lakh 2BHK may not be affordable for people living at Anjanapura.

Most importantly, the question that one has to raise is whether “affordability” gives the flexibility to tweak the very basic design parameters of a living environment – light and ventilation.

Today when we evaluate certain upcoming “affordable” projects in Bangalore, we see that the wings of the buildings are so closely packed that the window of bedrooms opens in the main entrance corridor of the building and some in which only one room has natural ventilation and the other windows are opening into a duct. You cannot avoid looking into your neighbour’s house while enjoying the Bengaluru weather in your balconies. It indeed brings sense of “community living”!

Statistics show that these projects have surprisingly sold their stock as hot cakes. These compartment apartments are selling at a lower price than the other projects in the vicinity and are actually affordable to the pocket. eg: Rs. 37 lacs 2BHK in HSR layout. Certainly, one sees that the real estate mantra of “location location and location” is catching up gradually and the importance of product is reducing.

However, it is undeniably inhuman to push the people to buy such houses in lieu of their affordability. These “smart spaces” are probably the resultants of consuming the entire FSI (Floor Space Index) and additional TDRs (Transferable Development Rights) within the same plot while maintaining the height restrictions. There seems to be some disconnect with the building byelaws and the quality of space one is finally aiming at.

Hopefully, the city fathers would look closely into the zoning regulations and upgrade the space standards before the city of Bengaluru starts overflowing with these architectural disasters.

Comments:

  1. Muralidhar C R says:

    our educated fools community cant understand whats affordable what is not simple to day for example person with 10000Rs per month income with even one kid can afford three mobile phones ironicaly they have and spend their hard earned money on mobile bills.the same apply to affordable houses if one can afford three mobiles with 10000rs in come per month

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Similar Story

Staying afloat: From Davanagere to Copenhagen, how cities are successfully battling urban floods

Amidst worsening Bengaluru floods, these local and global case studies open up new avenues of flood mitigation for the city to consider.

Bengaluru’s floods keep getting worse each year. Even before the monsoons arrived, the city was already submerged this year, raising serious questions about mitigation measures. While the state government continues to toot horns about more construction projects, like elevated corridors, tunnels and flyovers, basic storm water drain (SWD) infrastructure remains inadequate and incomplete, leading to urban flooding. For 2024-25, the Karnataka government has allocated ₹2,000 crore to the Bruhat Bengaluru Mahanagara Palike (BBMP) under the ‘Karnataka Water Security and Disaster Resilience Initiative.’ In a press release dated May 17, 2025, BBMP had identified 209 flood-prone areas in Bengaluru, with mitigation…

Similar Story

Are white-topped roads worsening flooding in Bengaluru? Experts weigh in

Concrete roads are not exactly the culprit; the problem lies in how the BBMP has designed and built these roads in Bengaluru.

‘We don’t want white-topped roads, as they increase waterlogging and don't allow water to percolate’ is a common sentiment among many Bengalureans. While drawing more and more water from Cauvery river, Bengaluru is doing little to recharge its groundwater. With the city extracting 100% of its groundwater, citizens don't get water even after drilling down to 1,800 feet. Yet BBMP is white-topping our roads over the existing asphalt, without structures like rain gardens or bioswales to capture stormwater. But are Bengalureans right in believing that white-topping worsens flooding? The answer is complicated. Do white-topped roads hinder water recharge? Hearing a…