Heritage vs development

The Hindu carried an interesting editorial late last year on developing heritage cities in India.

Most people don’t associate Bengaluru with heritage. While it is true that Bangalore has only a few monumental historic buildings like – two forts, two palaces and a scattering of temples.

What we do have is: a large network of tanks, plenty of trees and parks, and a number of historic zones. Places like Basavanagudi, Whitefield and Chickpet have a unique historic character defined by their architecture, layout and/or mix of communities and professions. Charming precincts like these are what drew people to Bangalore and gave it the ‘Garden City’ and ‘Pensioner’s Paradise’ epithets.

Today, unfortunately, Bangalore is a classic example of paving over paradise to put up parking lots.

To those who argue that losing heritage is inevitable if we want to modernise, I have only one word: London… though almost any European city could be taken as an example of how retaining our past need not be anti-development. Indeed, heritage protection can be a catalyst for sensitive development. Retaining the historic character of some of our city’s older areas, regenerating our lakes, protecting our parks and trees can all make our city liveable once more. It would also make the city more attractive for visitors.

And perhaps most important, heritage conservation usually leads to an enhanced sense of belonging and civic pride in an area’s residents, often a critical ingredient for further development of the area.

Comments:

  1. Manoj Gunwani says:

    A better example than London which has the benefit of being reeked in history are the heritage districts in Chinese cities such as the Kwan Zai area in Chengdu. They marry heritage preservation with commercial compulsions very well. Heritage can make money, it just needs the right people to do it.

  2. Nanda Ramesh says:

    Agree 100%. I live in Basavanagudi and cannot understand why the powers that be want to make the Gandhi-bazaar area more car-friendly. The beauty of it is the open markets and convenience (where possible) to pedestrians for shopping. Ideally, they traffic should be kept minimal and footpaths wide and large…to retain its charm.

  3. Meera Iyer says:

    Thanks for the info on the Chinese cities, Manoj. Would love to hear more on them. And Nanda, you’re so right about Basavanagudi. Several cities elsewhere in the world have taken up measure like traffic calming (forcing cars to slow down, sometimes by narrowing streets) for exactly the reason you give: keep traffic minimal and footpaths wide and large…to retain its charm.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Similar Story

Road to freedom: How this Chennai shelter empowers women with disabilities

A purpose-built, fully accessible space is helping women reclaim dignity, pursue education and sport, and advocate for systemic change.

When fifty-one-year-old Matilda Fonceca first wheeled herself through the gates of the Better World Shelter for women with disabilities in Chennai, she was not looking for transformation. She simply wanted a safe place to stay. The locomotor disability that has shaped her life since childhood has never stopped her from pursuing independence, yet it has often dictated how society has treated her. Much of her youth was spent moving between NGOs, where she learned early that institutions might make space for her, but rarely with her needs in mind. Before arriving here, Matilda lived an ordinary urban life, working night…

Similar Story

From shadows to spotlight: Youth in Mumbai’s Govandi rewrite their story through art

In the city’s most overlooked neighbourhood, the community rises above challenges to reclaim space and present the Govandi Arts Festival.

“For the last five years, I’ve only come to Govandi to report on crime or garbage,” admitted a reporter from a national newspaper during the Govandi Arts Festival 2023. “This is the first time I’m here to cover a story about art, and it’s one created by the youth themselves.” He went on to publish an article titled Govandi Arts Festival: Reimagining Inadequately Built Spaces Through Art and Creativity. It featured young artists who dared to tell their stories using their own voices and mediums. One might wonder why a place like Govandi, home to Mumbai’s largest resettlement population, burdened…