Students debate if law can prevent elder abuse

by June 30, 2010 Society

Senior citizens group Jnanajothi of Banashankari II Stage organised their 4th Annual V V Madhuranathan Memorial Debate Competition and saw students from eight schools participating in it.

Monday, June 21st saw 16 students from eight different schools participating in the 4th Annual V V Madhuranathan Memorial Debate Competition organised by Jnanajyothi, the Senior Citizens Association of Banashankari II Stage. The topic of the debate was "Law can prevent the abuse of elders by family members".

Jnanajothi debate

Participants in the debate competition, with the Jnanajothi team. Pic: Prasad

Students from standard 8th to 10th participated in this debate (some spoke in English while others spoke in Kannada) which was judged by a panel comprising of V R Kulkarni (Secretary, Swasahaya NGO), N B Jayaprakash (Director, Dignity Foundation Bengalooru Chapter) and Rekha Murthy (Officer-in-Charge, Help Age India, Bangalore).

Many who spoke against the topic felt that parents’ affection for children is much stronger than the law and that is why senior citizens rarely speak out when they are being abused. Further, older people worry about the potential fallout when dirty family linen is washed in public, and so do not speak up. The general perception that legal matters take a long time to resolve also added to the problem. So the law would be of little help to elders who were being abused – in all probability the abuse would continue and increase.

The general perception of the students speaking for the topic was that elders should start speaking up for their rights, and that the courts should work towards resolving such cases quickly.

Kirthana (JSS Public School) bagged the first prize, Rashmi K Swamy (Ahalya Bai School) came second while Roopashree (Prarthana School) stood third. The rolling shield was won by JSS Public School, Banashankari II Stage.

Vidya Kiran scheme recipients

Recipients of the Vidya Kiran Scheme. Pic: Prasad

In addition, as a part of its Vidya Kiran Scheme, which has been running for three years, Jnanajyothi distributed stationery kits to nearly 50 children (of domestic service providers and locality vendors) of class II to PUC.

Through such activities, Jnanajyothi is attempting to bridge the gap between people of different sections of society while also building a mutual support structure for elders and children in and around Banashankari II Stage.  ⊕

Sections:

About Deepa Vaishnavi V M

Deepa Vaishnavi is a freelance HR professional, soft skills trainer, citizen journalist, mental health advocate, and author of a book based on Indian mythology.
Read more by Deepa Vaishnavi V M

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Similar Story

Safety still out of reach: Everyday struggles of women with disabilities

by January 26, 2026 Society
Women with disabilities face increased risks in public and private spaces because of consent violations, unsafe surroundings and neglect.

Every morning, Samidha Dhumatkar travels from her home in Mumbai’s western suburbs to Churchgate, where she works as a telephone operator at a university campus. Her journey involves taking a rickshaw, boarding a train, and walking to her workplace, similar to thousands of other Mumbaikars who commute daily. However, as a person with a visual disability, Samidha’s commute is fraught with threats to her safety. In their book, Why Loiter? Women and Risk on Mumbai Streets, writers Shilpa Phadke, Sameera Khan, and Shilpa Ranade, argue that spaces are not neutral. Moreover, they are not designed equally. “Across geography and time,…

Continue reading

Similar Story

India’s stray dog debate puts the nation’s conscience on trial

by January 20, 2026 Society
Street dogs spark a national test — will India choose compassion or fear as law, humanity and coexistence come under strain?

At the heart of a nation’s character lies how it treats its most vulnerable. Today, India finds its soul stretched on a rack, its conscience torn between compassion and conflict, its legal pillars wobbling under the weight of a single, heartbreaking issue: the fate of its street dogs. What began as a Supreme Court suo moto hearing on August 11th has morphed into a national referendum on empathy, duty, and coexistence, exposing a deep, painful schism. Two sides Caregivers and animal lovers: They follow Animal Birth Control (ABC) and Catch-Neuter-Vaccinate-Return (CNVR). Their goal is to reduce dog populations and rabies…

Continue reading