High Court gives booster dose to RTI

A strict penalty imposed by a state Information Commission against an official was upheld by the judiciary. This might well act as a shot in the arm for the RTI movement.

In a boost to the Right To Information (RTI) movement in the country, the Punjab and Haryana High Court, in February this year, upheld the levy of penalty by the Haryana State Information Commission, on the State Public Information Officer (SPIO) for delay in furnishing information to an RTI applicant. The Commission had levied a fine of Rs.19250, at the rate of Rs.250 per day for a 77-day delay caused by the SPIO in servicing the RTI application.

CIC-VerdictCartoon: Narasimha Vedala

It is only recently that RTI users in Bangalore stumbled upon this case, and clearly, they are pleased. They pointed out that it sets a precedent for the State Information Commissions and empowers the public to act against errant public information officers who deliberately and malafidely delay or deny information to legitimate RTI applicants.

"The Karnataka Commission too has levied penalties in cases, but they have used their discretion on the amount," says RTI activist Anil Kumar. "The RTI Act is clear that it is Rs.250 per day of delay, so we don’t know under what clause Karnataka Commission uses their discretion. They have even levied Rs.500 as penalty in one case," adds Kumar.

"I should congratulate the Punjab and Haryana High Court for this judgment which is a very good one for RTI," says Kumar.

The case in question pertains to an RTI application of October 2006 made to the Kurukshetra University, Haryana. Dismissing an appeal by the SPIO against the levy of penalty by the State Information Commission, the High Court noted that the RTI applicant was made to wait beyond the stipulated 30-day period. He had to then appeal before the Commission which was the Second Appellate Authority under the RTI Act.

The Commission asked him to go to the First Appellate Authority not knowing that it did not exist and so he had to come back to the Commission. The First Appellate Authority was constituted only later.

All this back and forth caused the delay of 77 days before the applicant got the information he wanted. The Commission acting upon the powers entrusted to it under the Act then imposed a penalty on the SPIO. The Commission said that the SPIO was not able to show that the delay occured due to reasonable cause. "In fact the SPIO has acted in a most casual manner in processing the application with the result that there has been a delay of 77 days in furnishing the information," the Commission noted.

The SPIO then petitioned the High Court against the Commission’s order, which the Court dismissed, and upheld the penalty.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Similar Story

Mumbai Buzz: TapTap wristbands for Metro passengers | Double property tax without Marathi signboards… and more

In other news in Mumbai: Unaided school teachers on election duty; Coastal Road to be connected to Sea Link; Underpass on Coastal Road submerged.

TapTap wristbands for metro passengers Passengers on the Metro 1 line, which runs from Ghatkopar to Versova, will have a new ticketing option in the near future. Mumbai Metro One Pvt Ltd (MMOPL) has introduced a QR-coded wristband dubbed TapTap.  Passengers will be able to tap their wristbands at the automated fare collection gate (AFC). With an inaugural price of Rs 200, these wearable metro tickets are available at all customer care windows on the metro line. According to MMOPL, the TapTap wristbands are made of a silicone based material that is non-allergenic. They are water-proof and operate without a battery.…

Similar Story

Chennai Buzz: Road repairs affected by election | Membership increases in Anna Library… and more

In other news from Chennai: Residents of Kannappar Thidal boycott Lok Sabha polls; Semmenchery residents to get piped water supply

Kannappar Thidal residents of Chennai Central constituency to boycott Lok Sabha elections In line with the villagers of Ennore and Parandur, residents of Kannappar Thidal in Chennai's Central constituency have also decided to boycott the upcoming Lok Sabha elections. Around 62 families, who were living on the streets near the Ripon building, were evicted in 2002 by the Greater Chennai Corporation (GCC) as their presence was found to be an obstacle to the then-ongoing sporting events and developmental work in the nearby Jawaharlal Nehru Stadium. These families were provided with a temporary shelter with a promise of alternative housing in…