Jurisdiction problem: No takers for garbage

The garbage dumped in an area that falls in between S K Garden and Jayamahal remained untouched since 15 May 2013; The Congress councillors of both wards got busy shifting the blame on one another.

The garbage dumped in an area that falls in between S K Garden and Jayamahal has remained untouched since 15 May 2013; The Congress councillors of both wards are busy shifting the blame on one another.

What do garbage contractors do when they need to dispose of the garbage lying in a border area, in between two wards? Do nothing, leave the garbage where it is. The easy excuse is, it is not in their limit.

One such case was reported in Benson town, at a road that lies between S K Garden (ward 61) and Jayamahal (ward 63). The street in question is on the junction of Harris Road and Bore Bank Road. One side of this street falls in the S K Garden ward while the buildings opposite fall in Jayamahal ward limits. This was brought to Citizen Matters’ attention by Sanchia de Souza, who lives in Benson Town, nearby the spot in question.

Sanchia explains how it all started: “On Wednesday 15 May, 2013 at 1.30 am, a garbage van turned up and a very drunk contractor dumped garbage collected from elsewhere at the spot, even though our neighbours tried to stop him from doing so. We tried to first follow up with the contractor for the S K Garden area, requesting him to collect the garbage and take it to where it has to go. But he has not taken any action.”


Garbage dumped on the border of S K Garden and Jayamahal wards. Pic: Hemanth Uchil

The residents brought the matter to the attention of Devikarani Sridhar, S K Garden corporator, and Gunashekhar, the councillor for Jayamahal ward. “On 19 May 2013, Sunday, we made a complaint to the BBMP itself, got a complaint number and were promised that it would be cleared in six hours. However, both garbage contractors and both councillors are continuing to say that this spot is not their responsibility,” says Sanchia.

When the residents approached, Corporator of S K Garden Devikarani Sridhar was not available for comment. Corporator of Jayamahal Gunashekhar agreed to take up the issue in the council, but insisted that the spot in question is not his responsibility.

Both these wards fall under the BBMP East Zone, but while S K Garden ward (No. 61) belongs to the Pulakeshinagara constituency, Jayamahal ward (No. 63) comes under Shivajinagara constituency.

‘Not my area’

Citizen Matters approached Manjunath, the garbage contractor for Jayamahal ward, for a reaction on the issue. He insisted that nobody under his supervision has dumped the waste. “The garbage seems to be coming from the Kavalbyrasandra (ward 32) of the K G Halli sub-division, Pulakeshinagara constituency,” he added. “The spot where the garbage has been dumped is 15 yards away from where the corporator, M K Gunashekhar had got it tarred last year. So strictly, it falls in the S K Garden area,” he asserted.

Devikarani told Citizen Matters that there is no official garbage contractor for her ward and the waste disposal is managed by the BBMP office on orders from the Joint Commissioner. She also denied the area as coming under her ward. “The right side of Harris road is S K Garden and the left is Jayamahal. The garbage is coming from Corporator Gunashekhar’s ward. There is also a choultry near the area from where most of this waste comes and all of it is dumped on the spot in question” she told Citizen Matters.

When asked if she has spoken to Gunashekhar regarding this issue she said, “Not yet. But he and I belong to the same party (INC) and we have decided that we will talk this out and resolve it today (Wednesday).” She explained that even though they get it cleaned in the morning, by afternoon the garbage van dumps it there again.

‘No longer my problem’

Though Gunashekhar had assured immediate action when contacted by the citizens earlier, he had something different to say when contacted by Citizen Matters. “They come and dump it in the night so we do not have any idea who did this. But this spot is off my ward limits. I have spoken to the engineer of ward number 61 (S K Garden) and he said that he would clean it up. Their engineer himself has taken the responsibility to clean it up,” clarified Gunashekhar, addign that “now it is no longer my problem.”

Citizen Matters also contacted Rukkanna, Assistant Executive Engineer, BBMP whose work involves looking into disposal of garbage at the sub-division in question. He said, “I was not aware of this till now. But will attend to it right away and will get the garbage cleared by today afternoon.”

While the councillors were busy throwing the ball into one another’s court, the residents did not t seem to understand how a spot in the middle of the city is apparently not a part of any ward under the BBMP.

At the time of this article getting published, Sridhar, husband of Devikarani, the Corporator of S K Garden, was supervising the cleaning up process, even as he continued to put the blame on the other corporator.


  1. keerthikumar says:

    At present garbage has no problem,since it was in news,now vacant sites and storm water drains filled with garbage.How BBMP given contract nobody knows,and how contractors getting payments.First clean the storm water drains other wise if it rains there is health hazzard and rain water will flow to all house.The newly elected city MLA’s should take this challenge work immediately.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Similar Story

Taking flight: Does Chennai need a second airport and at what cost?

Civic and environmental activists question the feasibility of the greenfield airport in Parandur and suggest expansion of Chennai airport.

Ten lakes, two streams, 3,500 acres of agricultural land, 1,005 families and hundreds of plant and animal species β€” these are all under threat because of one development project. There has been a considerable buzz regarding the Chennai Greenfield Airport set to come up in Parandur on the outskirts of the city. But, not all the noise is positive. Villagers in Parandur have been protesting for almost 700 days and some have even boycotted the Lok Sabha 2024 elections, asking the government to withdraw the project.   Yet, work is steadily progressing on the greenfield airport and the government is…

Similar Story

Explainer: Electrical components and ways to increase BESCOM sanctioned load

Here is an explainer on electrical system components and its maintenance, how to calculate sanction load and the process to increase it.

(Part 1 covered the components of BESCOM bill, tariff structure and sanction loads. Part 2 delves into electrical system maintenance) With the adoption of electric vehicles, owners are tapping into their existing meters to charge their vehicles, leading to electrical mishaps. If you need to connect a 3.3 kw/7.2kw EV charger, your sanctioned load needs to be enhanced. This leads to cable/wire, MCB (miniature circuit breaker) and RCCB (residual current circuit breaker) replacement, possibly the energy meter too may need to be replaced.  Overall, if every household enhances sanction load, this leads to constant tripping of the transformer and short…