Supermarket no to basement car-parking irks citizens

Can a supermarket with sanctioned parking for cars open it only for two-wheelers? This has caused citizens to pursue the matter doggedly, unexpectedly unearthing major violations.

Residents of Dollars Colony in J P Nagar 4th phase are complaining of increasing traffic jams at the 8th main road-2nd cross intersection. The cause they say is the M K Ahmed super market located at the intersection.

Sign at the entrance (8th Main Road) of the basement restricting parking to two-wheelers. Pic: Yogaraj Mudalgi.

K V R Somayaji, at IT consultant in his fifties, who lives opposite the store on 2nd cross says that the store is not allowing car parking in the basement, leading to customers parking on busy 8th Main. A city no-parking sign prohibits parking of vehicles for 200 feet along 8th main.

The BBMP plan sanction approved for the building shows parking of seven cars, and "it shall not be used for any other purpose", notes Somayaji. D Nisar Ahmed is the owner of the building. A copy of the BBMP-approved plan, obtained through Right to Information (RTI) Act was provided to Citizen Matters by Somayaji.

"We have restricted parking to two-wheelers in the basement only because there is not enough space for four-wheelers to be parked. We also request customers to not park along 8th main," says K Sadiq, Manager of the M K Ahmed store. For his part, Nisar Ahmed, owner of the building put the ball back in the store’s court by saying that the basement is for the use of everyone in the building and he has not restricted car parking.

When Citizen Matters visited the store (three occasions), signs restricted posted by the store restricted parking to only two-wheelers, however, there were no traffic jams at that time.

The swanky looking building housing the supermarket is in Dollars Colony, J P Nagar, one block away from the Delmia intersection. Pic: YM.

The matter has gotten further complicated when citizens unearthed additional building violations. While the plan sanction is for a ground plus two storey structure, the owner has built an extra floor. The JP Nagar Fourth Phase Dollars Colony Residents’ Welfare Association,

through RTI also found out that Nisar Ahmed had not obtained the Completion Certificate and Occupancy Certificate (OC) for the building. The OC is mandatory for obtaining electricity and water connections. A copy of BBMP’s RTI response stating this is with Citizen Matters.

M K Ahmed Store manager Sadiq points ut that they are only the tenants and are not responsible for any violations. Nisar Ahmed denies committing any plan violations.

BBMP’s JP Nagar Assistant Executive Engineer K Venkatesh could not be reached for comment. "I get hundreds of complaints like this", says Ananth Swamy, his superior, Executive Engineer (South). He asked Citizen Matters for an SMS with the full address of the building, adding that he was going to look into the violations.

Comments:

  1. Shaik Althaf says:

    Dear Mr Yogaraj S Mudalgi,

    Its difficult to construct a building without violations. Try building a house or commercial building you will come to know how outdated our building bye laws are which will force you to deviate from the sanctioned plan . Which is very well known by the officials & our great politicians and they take total advantage of this fact.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Similar Story

Praja’s Citizen Manifesto calls for transparency, equity in Mumbai’s governance

As Mumbai gets ready for BMC polls, Praja’s Citizen Manifesto demands better services, access to civic data, and citizen participation in governance.

The much-awaited elections to the richest civic body, Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC), are expected to take place soon. Mumbai has not had elected representatives for over three years. The term of the previous corporators ended in March 2022.  As Mumbaikars ready themselves to cast their votes, Praja Foundation, an organisation working to hold governments accountable, has brought out a 'Citizens' Manifesto' for Maharashtra. The manifesto calls for improvement in core urban services, open and free access to municipal data, protection of the urban environment, and better citizen participation and accountability. The manifesto calls for urgent reforms and gives a practical roadmap…

Similar Story

Insights from theatre workshops: Empowering Mumbai’s young women through civic education

Over 300 participants in Civis’ Civic Sisterhood Campaign learnt about constitutional rights and tools to hold the government accountable.

The constant looking over one's shoulder, being followed on the street, inappropriate touch and harassment on public transportation — every woman is familiar with this narrative. It was these issues that were highlighted when groups of young women in Mumbai were asked to create tableaux, depicting their everyday experiences, during a  recent theatre workshop. While the workshop facilitators did not set a specific theme, something striking happened. Group after group independently chose to portray the same issues: street harassment, eve teasing, gender discrimination and domestic violence. These were no longer just abstract concerns but pressing realities shaping how young women…