Why pay taxes when garbage not cleared, potholes not filled?

Time has to come to start a new kind of Satyagraha in Bengaluru, as the civic body governing the city has failed in all aspects of administration.

October 2 brings the annual ritual obeisance to the Father of the Nation, but in the last six decades we have not had a repetition of the kind of protests against injustice on the scale that Gandhiji undertook during his salt march or Quit India movement.

However, this time around, there is talk of a satyagraha, no less, by citizens of Bengaluru, because judging from the meetings I have been witness to over the last three months, patience is running thin. It is, many
residents are now saying, time to undertake collective action, to make our voices heard. Not against a colonial ruler – we are free – but as one impassioned speaker put it last week, “We are not free – from garbage and filth and the incompetence of a city corporation that seems fully helpless against mismanagement and complete lack of accountability, in ensuring rudimentary cleanliness and safety from disease.”

No change in garbage piles

Despite daily visuals and comments in the newspapers, the city has more piles of garbage today than a year ago. We pay taxes as property owners and residents, and are entitled to a clean environment, observed a gathering of representatives of RWAs held recently. Since last year, we have also been paying an extra SWM (solid waste management) cess, but after more than a year of discussions, in the legislature, in the media and even by judges in courts, about garbage piling up, we are nowhere near even marginal betterment.

Neighbourhood meetings have had lawyers (explaining about public interest litigation procedures) corporators (conceding helplessness against vested interests in garbage disposal tenders etc), medical officers (of the BBMP as well as hospital workers and independent doctors) and representatives of the corporate world, trying to seek solutions. The consensus is that our voices are not making a dent at all.

When the chief minister announced an ‘inspection tour’ a few days ago, the BBMP quickly cleared garbage and filled potholes overnight, but only along the route that the CM was going to take. The rest of us, even in upmarket neighbourhoods, can succumb to dengue, malaria, and typhoid, and risk life and limb when we set out for work, along roads with thousands of potholes.

Last month, a friend of mine was knocked down by a two-wheeler that swerved to avoid a pothole in Vidyaranyapura. He died. He was a Padmavibhushan – but potholes are filled pronto only for political VIPs. Others do not count. As RWAs and activists are saying, enough is enough. We have seen a series of deadlines for a “garbage free city,” since early 2012, with no political will to actually enforce action.

Why pay taxes?

Which is why there is now a burgeoning move to offer “Satyagraha” in the form of refusal to pay property tax which is due in April. Some associations are already implementing their own garbage disposal projects, even in small residential blocks. In which case, they are asking, what are the taxes collected for? Those subscribing to this argument include high profile achievers and professionals.

BBMP moans about shortage of funds, and  is proposing various impositions to raise money. Citizens in increasing numbers are convinced that money is not the problem. Even corporators and MLAs, speaking off the records, have conceded that it is the mafia hold over garbage disposal that is the crux of the problem. If a city administration is unable to tackle this and restore the rule of law, where are we heading?

At the RWA meetings I attended, anger against the ineffectiveness of the corporation seems pervasive. At one recent meeting, it was suggested by one participant that we launch a Satyagraha on October 2, to claim our rights to a clean environment, as citizens.

I know an activist who sent a registered notice to the then commissioner Bharat Lal Meena with signatures from 28 families along just one road, seeking action because of the rising incidence of chikungunya caused by filth and mosquitoes. There was not even an acknowledgement. The Rs 27 paid for registration of the letter, was a complete waste. That official moved on, to another department.

Last year the High Court had threatened to supersede the corporation. Even that has not brought any relief to us. As one citizen remarked after last week’s meeting of neighbourhood groups, “Politicians and chief ministers come and go, IAS officers come and go, but the garbage piles have remained, a horrendous indictment of governance and administrative sloth.” So, the Satyagraha could vent the anger and disillusionment sweeping over increasing numbers of residents. Wait and watch for updates.

Related Articles

Amidst rising stink, BBMP drafts new garbage policy
BBMP accepts blame for garbage mess. But what next?


  1. Sethuraman Vembu says:

    In New Thippasandra area the BBMP cleaners demand monthly payment to collect the garbage failing which they just refuse to clear the garbage.


  2. srinivasan dr sundaram says:

    When we read today’s 26th times of india we feel like to putting our heads down in shame for electing corporators and counsellors who made a mockery of uss and our money while in the purpose of visiting a garbage treatment process at salem these elected members have spent rs 3 lacs plus going and spending time as if it is a FUN and eating and returning. it is reported that many except the minister and one or two the other’s went out as if this is an an excursion . we have to suffer for electing the people who have no ethics,responsibility and accountability to daringly misuses our hard earned money. please read the ext and see the photos. Where is the scope for them to deliver to the public.

  3. Rashmi Bala Gupta says:

    This garbage piling and its disposal is going on since more than a year. BBMP doesn’t have funds to take action on any problem but it has funds to waste Rs. 3,00000/- to go to Salem with minister, commissioner, 40 staff members and two buses to have picnic and shooting pictures, nobody bothering about seeing garbage recycle plant for which they have spent this much of money. They misuse collected taxes and cess for this purpose without bothering what people are facing, in Yesterday’s TOI one girl Arnita suffered many fractures due to pothole and will be in the hospital for more than three months. They are least bothered about sufferings of residents. Bangalore which is an IT hub known all over the world is facing such an apathy, what to say of other cities?

  4. srinivasan dr sundaram says:

    every one like us has tales of woes to tell. but what/where is the solution? There are several risks in undertaking a mass movement in the current scenario risk to life, risk to property risk to family etc etc.There should be rebellion against each action of govt if they are not public centric. there is lawlessness and goondaism everywhere.. bureaucrats and politicians have muscle and money power. But still a strong, united unidirectional focussed team can teach them a lesson.Let God save us till then

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Similar Story

What is the ‘smartness’ quotient of Chennai?

The Smart City Advisory Forum was convened in Chennai only 5 times since 2016, showing minimal participation by elected representatives.

Chennai is among the first few cities to get selected under the Smart City Mission programme in 2016. As many as 48 projects under different categories were taken up under the scheme. With only a couple of projects left to be completed, isn't Chennai supposed to look 'smart' now? The much-hyped Central government scheme, launched in 2014, was envisioned to build core infrastructure and evolve 'smart' solutions that would make cities more livable and sustainable. But, a decade since, the reality on the ground may be a little different. While some of the facilities provided under these projects are under-utilised,…

Similar Story

Scenes from a community walk in Mumbai

When I moved to Mumbai, the city felt extremely 'walkable,' but a walking tour in Dadar broadened my definition of walkability.

When I moved to Mumbai in June 2023 for work, I found myself going for sight seeing to the city's tourist destinations. Though the city appeared to have consistent and wide footpaths almost everywhere, vehicular right of way seemed to be prioritised over the pedestrian right of way. This struck me as very strange, even as I continued to enjoy walking through lanes of Mumbai very much. On one hand, there is excellent footpath coverage, utilised by large crowds everywhere. On the other hand, speeding vehicles create obstacles for something as simple as crossing the road.  "Though Mumbai appeared to…