Recreational activities in lake premises: What is wrong with it?

Among the many issues raised by the recent event at Sankey Tank. One is - can this set a precedent for BBMP to lease out our parks, lakes, or wetlands? An ecologist from Bangalore ponders over the issue.

There are several issues – short term, medium term and long term, that I see with the RedBull FlugTag event held at Sankey Tank premises in Malleshwaram, Bangalore.

1. Short term

From the photographs I have seen of the aftermath, the areas around Sankey Tank appear littered with rubbish, with trash all around the lake and in the lake as well, including non-biodegradables like thermocol. The impact on the fish, birds and other lake wildlife that ingest this thermocol can only be imagined. During events like this, the noise and bright lights also add to the disturbance to urban wildlife. Lakes are not pure spaces for urban recreation: many different urban wildlife species inhabit these environments. 

2. Medium term

This kind of an event can set a precedent for BBMP and other government agencies to lease out other urban nature commons: our parks, our lakes, our wetlands, even areas like the Turahalli forest, for commercial ventures. This is a clear violation of the directions provided by the Karnataka High Court Committee headed by Justice N K Patil, whose directions were provided for good reason. Previous efforts by government agencies such as the LDA to privatise lakes were shot down by the court after PILs were filed by ESG. This seems to be another entry for privatisation of our commons, via the back door.

3. Long term

This leads to the third, long term impact of such events, which I think is the most significant. There has been much discussion in the media, public meetings and in online groups about how to plan for the sustainability of our commons. Unfortunately, although ‘sustainability’ in this context originally begins with ecological sustainability, the issue frequently gets transmogrified and starts to refer to economic sustainability. People and planners start to suggest approaches by which lakes can provide income generation through corporate funding.

Yet, it all comes back to the question of why do we think we need to conserve these lakes. Conservation for what, by whom? If a lake is made financially viable by generating income through motorised boating, opening theme parks, creating food courts, and renting out space for commercial events: is this still a lake? If so, organisations who open commercial zoos should be providing a more financial path to conserve wildlife – much more economically sustainable than protecting forests. Should we then cut down all our forests and transform them into paid-entry zoos? The farcical nature of this argument becomes immediately obvious when we put it in such stark comparison, yet it seems that many see nothing wrong in suggesting solutions such as these to manage our lakes.

Such thinking results in a transformation of the social conception of the lake, from an ecological commons that is open to all, to a recreational space, open only for those who can pay. The lake as an ecological commons shelters birds, fishes and reptiles, provides livelihoods for traditional communities such as fishers and fodder collectors, constitutes a sacred zone for local communities, a meeting space for people, and creates a location of serenity and inspiration for the nature-starved in the city.

Why convert this into a noisy, conventional urban recreational space with loudspeakers, event managers, bright lights, television crew, and an associated Facebook page? Quite obviously, our cities are not starved of commercial recreational spaces. Yet urban commons are probably one of the most endangered land use categories across the country, and provide a resource for the most underprivileged and dispossessed of urban dwellers, who get entirely left out of these conversations around use and access. 

Subordinating the issue of sustainable management of our urban commons to issues focused on economic sustenance would be a tragedy. Unfortunately, this is the long term discourse that we can see events such as the RedBull FlugTag moving us towards.

Related Articles

Red Bull Flugtag at Sankey Tank amidst controversy
Waste handler firm works on Sankey Tank cleanup post Flugtag

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Similar Story

Opinion: Why climate action must recognise and include India’s informal workers

As COP29 discusses ways to mitigate the climate crisis, India must address the adversities faced by informal workers and chalk out plans.

The ongoing COP29 conference in Baku, is a pivotal moment in climate action, focusing on global cooperation to limit warming to 1.5°C. Key priorities include mobilising financial resources for developing countries to submit ambitious climate plans (NDCs) by 2025 and continuing support through the Fund for Loss and Damage (FRLD) established at COP28. COP29 also aims to strengthen adaptation efforts by setting finance-backed targets for the Global Goal on Adaptation.  While COP29 primarily focuses on international climate initiatives, India must address pressing domestic issues. One key group often overlooked is informal workers in Indian cities. Over 80% of India’s urban…

Similar Story

Status check: Key concerns remain as Chennai moves ahead with WTE plans

Greater Chennai Corporation's tender for the Waste-To-Energy plant is at the final stage; Here is what we know about the bidders

17,422 metric tonnes per day — that's the staggering amount of trash the Greater Chennai Corporation (GCC) will generate in 30 years. Currently, Chennai produces 6,143 metric tonnes of waste daily, which adds to the growing piles in Kodungaiyur and Perungudi dump yards. Like many other major cities, GCC is struggling to find a sustainable solution for waste management and has proposed a Waste-To-Energy (WTE) plant. However, the experiences of cities like Delhi are testimony to the significant environmental and health impacts of WTE plants. A recent The New York Times investigative report on the Delhi WTE reveals: "The government…