Hard-won step forward, but many more miles to go!

18 corporators of BBMP became members of the first Metropolitan Planning Committee of the Bangalore region. This is an important and hard-won step forward in getting a proper planning body for the city. There are many drawbacks in the way the MPC has been constituted, but at least we have an institution that is supposed to do the planning now. Making it work effectively is another ballgame altogether, and we must work with the State government to properly devolve powers to this body and give it some real teeth to fix the city.

Around the country, only a few MPCs have been formed, and these too are not usually allowed to run well by the state governments. In Maharashtra, the CM made himself a member of the Mumbai MPC and the Pune MPC and the Nagpur MPC. That effectively killed all three of them. Here too, according to the notification, the CM is likely to be a member of the Bangalore, Mysore, and Hubli-Dharward MPCs.

This is totally un-necessary. A Chief Minister has so much work to do in leading the state that he should cede the city space to a different set of people, and let these institutions work well. But somehow our politics has not matured enough to see that different levels of government are not supposed to be in a hierarchical relationship, but that they should perform different functions. One day that wisdom will dawn, but sadly for our country, these things always happen later than sooner.

Congratulations to CK Ramamurthy and others who were made members today. Best wishes to help make Namma Bengaluru – not just the city, but the region – a great metropolis.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Similar Story

Check how your MPs have performed in Parliament (and here’s why)

From 100% attendance to only 26%, how did your MP perform this Budget Session? See who is truly representing your voice in our MP Tracker.

When Ranjan Gogoi, the former Chief Justice of India, retired from the Rajya Sabha two months ago, his performance in Parliament became a matter of debate. As per an analysis by Livelaw, Gogoi did not ask a question to the government even once during the six years of his tenure and participated in the debate on only one Bill.  More recently, when seven AAP MPs defected to BJP, another analysis by Indian Express revealed that one of these seven defecting MPs, Harbhajan Singh, a former cricketer, had only 26% attendance.  Why do we typically go around digging data on the…

Similar Story

Deepening reservoirs, rainwater harvesting: Sustainable alternatives to the Mamallan dam

Why Mamallan reservoir? Experts say Chennai's water future lies in greener solutions — desilting old reservoirs and maintaining neglected tanks.

Ever since the contentious Mamallan reservoir was proposed in the ecosensitive Kovalam–Nemmeli backwater system, fisher communities in Chennai have repeatedly asked: Does it have to be here? Experts and scientists say no, urging the government to abandon the project and work on sustainable alternatives.  Critics point to a long list of costs: high expenditure, land acquisition, and risks to livelihoods and biodiversity. As we have reported earlier, the central concern driving the project is the looming drinking water supply crisis – demand is projected to rise from 1,100 million litres a day (MLD) to over 2,500 MLD for the Greater…