Hard-won step forward, but many more miles to go!

by September 16, 2014 Governance

18 corporators of BBMP became members of the first Metropolitan Planning Committee of the Bangalore region. This is an important and hard-won step forward in getting a proper planning body for the city. There are many drawbacks in the way the MPC has been constituted, but at least we have an institution that is supposed to do the planning now. Making it work effectively is another ballgame altogether, and we must work with the State government to properly devolve powers to this body and give it some real teeth to fix the city.

Around the country, only a few MPCs have been formed, and these too are not usually allowed to run well by the state governments. In Maharashtra, the CM made himself a member of the Mumbai MPC and the Pune MPC and the Nagpur MPC. That effectively killed all three of them. Here too, according to the notification, the CM is likely to be a member of the Bangalore, Mysore, and Hubli-Dharward MPCs.

This is totally un-necessary. A Chief Minister has so much work to do in leading the state that he should cede the city space to a different set of people, and let these institutions work well. But somehow our politics has not matured enough to see that different levels of government are not supposed to be in a hierarchical relationship, but that they should perform different functions. One day that wisdom will dawn, but sadly for our country, these things always happen later than sooner.

Congratulations to CK Ramamurthy and others who were made members today. Best wishes to help make Namma Bengaluru – not just the city, but the region – a great metropolis.

Sections:

About Ashwin Mahesh

Ashwin Mahesh is an urbanist, journalist, technologist and scientist. He is a co-founder of India Together, one of India’s first public affairs journals. He also co-founded the social technology firm, Mapunity in 2006, and the electric vehicles-based transportation company, Lithium, in 2014. He is currently the CEO of his latest initiative, LVBL Accelerator, founded in 2023. He is also a trustee at Oorvani Foundation.
Read more by Ashwin Mahesh

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Similar Story

Give the poor homes or allow them to build? Ambedkar Nagar may hold the answer

by and April 22, 2025 Governance
The residents of the resettlement site in Chennai have made gradual upgrades to their homes, but are yet to get formal land titles from the government.

Across Indian cities, resettlement policies have often failed to provide long-term solutions for displaced communities, leaving them with insecure tenure, inadequate infrastructure, and limited growth opportunities. These challenges become even more apparent in resettlement schemes such as Chennai's Perumbakkam, where displaced communities were relocated into government-built apartments nearly 30 kilometres away. Antony, one of the first allottees of a plot in Chennai's Ambedkar Nagar, compares plots and apartments. He explains that having land allows gradual construction and improvements. "This is best. Here, with land, we can construct over time. There (in Perumbakkam), they cannot. There, even if they have money,…

Continue reading

Similar Story

Making the invisible visible: Why Bengaluru needs effective groundwater monitoring

by April 16, 2025 Governance
Ten assessment points in Bengaluru are over-exploited for groundwater, while government bodies lack the resources for effective monitoring.

Monitoring groundwater level is like keeping a tab on your income and expenses—if you are spending more, it is a warning sign. You can cut down spending or find ways to earn more. Similarly, a city must decide whether to reduce extraction in certain areas or improve recharge methods, such as rainwater harvesting, wastewater treatment, or preserving open spaces. So, does Bengaluru have enough groundwater monitoring systems? While a WELL Labs report estimates the city's groundwater consumption as 1,392 million litres a day (MLD), BWSSB’s groundwater outlook report states that the extraction is only 800 MLD. This suggests a significant…

Continue reading