Managing waste needs a deeper understanding, no cosmic solutions!

We need more than provocative articles to set the Dry Waste Collection Mechanism right.

In recent times, two newspapers (Deccan Chronicle and Times of India) have featured the Dry Waste Collection Centres of Bengaluru, in the guise of an ‘expose,’ leaving tan ignorant reader with a distasteful feeling with the use of dramatic phrases – to name a few, ‘Misuse by waste-pickers’, ‘Waste of public money by allowing the centers to become money spinners for private enterprises,’ ’Dark side of the DWCC underbelly.’ One of the articles has quoted the source as a study / report done by two citizens. 

As an SWM practitioner working closely with the BBMP and with the several NGOs /private enterprises that are running these DWCCs, I find the value judgment of waste pickers, scrap dealers, private enterprises, that comes through these two article features unjustified and unacceptable. This judgment denies the pragmatism of an economic view that an informal sector be provided a chance to bring their skills and experience to a formal sector, and be allowed to run them as a means of respectable self-sustenance.

The inclusion of waste pickers and the informal sector by the Municipality in solid waste management is in fact directed as necessary by the Government. The BBMP is the first Urban Local Body (ULB) in the country to issue ID cards to waste pickers and allow for their formal inclusion with the DWCCs.

Having been closely associated with a number of researchers and interns who have studied the changes in the SWM arena in Bangalore over the last few years, the approach of the report and the paper features leaves me to conclude that it ends up just posing a barrage of questions expecting someone to answer, while taking pot shots at those involved, the BBMP, NGOs and experts.

The conclusions seem more like cynical value judgments drawn from an experiential level – Can the BBMP do better..? Can DWCCs be operationally more efficient..? Can more be done on implementing the segregation at source..?

The answer is an overwhelming… Yes, of course!

However, we need more than provocative articles doing cosmetic reporting to set it right. The press serves an important role of scrutiny but in this case, the hidden insinuations and mischaracterisation are performing the almost exact opposite function of limiting a powerful social empowerment movement. 

The journey that Bangalore has embarked on to clean up its act on SWM needs a deeper understanding that can only come through commitment, long term engagement to bring about solutions to a multi-faceted problem like municipal solid waste management.

Comments:

  1. Shashidhar K. G. says:

    Well said, Ms Sandhya,
    In fact it all starts with us and I’m not sure if the reporters themselves practise segregation at their homes?!
    However, BBMP also needs to do more at the grass roots level eg- push carts, training of PK’s, involvement of the BBMP ward level staff who also segregate the mixed waste etc, etc.BBMP should also enforce the rules at the ground level too.
    Shashidhar/RTRA

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Similar Story

Garudachar palya: The “hot spot” in Whitefield’s IT Hub

Examining the heat island effect in densely built-up Garudachar Palya ward in Whitefield’s IT Hub, which also has limited tree cover.

Garudachar Palya is part of Mahadevapura constituency, with an area of 6.5 sq km, which includes four revenue villages — Garudachar Palya, Hoodi, Seegehalli, and Nallurahalli. These villages have stayed mostly the same, while the city has expanded around them with more organised development from the BDA. This mismatch has led to issues like narrow village lanes becoming crowded with traffic, as they’re now used as shortcuts to bypass main roads. Looking at population growth, between 2011 and 2024, the ward has seen an estimated increase of 62.24%. This rapid growth adds to the existing strain on infrastructure. Ward no…

Similar Story

Saving Dwarka Forest: Citizens approach apex court to protect forest land near Delhi airport

Delhi’s Dwarka Forest has seen brazen destruction thanks to a railway redevelopment project. A recent SC stay order has raised hopes.

According to a recent World Bank report, India presently accounts for a meagre 1.8% of the global forest cover. Even more concerning is the fact that an enormous ‘46,759 acres of forest-land have been sanctioned for mining’ across the country, over the course of the last five years, by the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change (MoEFCC) itself. According to many ace climate scientists and researchers, our planet has already hit “the tipping point”. In this backdrop, the people’s struggle to save Dwarka Forest, one of the last remaining natural forest lands in a choking capital city, is a…