Lawmakers splurge on renovations, while hospitals ignore the poor

No money to check stray dogs menace, or ensure proper working of government hospitals. Meanwhile government is to spend on renovations and clubhouses.

On 21 October, when the newspapers carried reports about the move to convert Balabrooie (the government guest house next to Chitra Kala Parishad) into a club house for legislators, there was also another news item. A toddler was mauled by stray dogs. The grievously injured child was rushed by his migrant labourer parents to the BBMP hospital in the area, but there were no specialist doctors available. So the toddler had to be taken to KIMS hospital at Chamarajapet. Thereafter the child had to be shifted yet again, to a hospital at Malleswaram.

Hospitals, especially government hospitals meant for those who cannot afford expensive treatment, turn away patients. Making the parents run around, from JP Nagar to Chamarajapet to Malleswaram is shameful and shows lack of accountability on the part of the state administration.

I don’t know if legislators are hanging their heads in shame and guilt, but certainly many of us, ordinary citizens are. Shame on multiple counts – this is not the first time that stray dogs attack a child, there exists a “dog squad” in the corporation, with staff drawing monthly salaries, who seem to do nothing.

In any other country, the corporation would be sued for hefty compensation, but a poor daily wage migrant worker does not sue, so it is “business as usual” for the dog squad, right ? Even a middle class family would be hard pressed to manage shifting of grievously injured child from one hospital to another; who pays the migrant labourer for all this transport?

The state has a minister in charge of hospitals, and various babus who get paid salaries to oversee the working of government hospitals and clinics. Instead of pulling them up, our legislators want to treat themselves to a club house, that too, by demolishing the state guest house which has one of the few expanses of greenery left in the city.

Legislators’ assembly hall is being upgraded with new carpets and fancy upholstered sofas and new toilets, costing Rs 17 crores (paid for from taxpayers’ money of course) but a poor family with a bleeding child has to run around from one area to another because government hospitals are not staffed properly! Another Rs 7 crore was spent a few weeks ago, for renovations at Vidhan Soudha’s legislative council hall.

Money is apparently not a problem. There’s plenty of it, for those who live it up at state expense. But no money—or more importantly, no political will or responsibility –to check stray dogs menace, or ensure proper working of government hospitals. Club house, indeed ! This is obscene, and a modern version of Nero fiddling while Rome burned.

It could be your – or my – child next, or one of us adults, bitten by dogs, and made to run from one hospital to another for emergency treatment. As educated urban citizens, can we let our legislators run amuck like this? If you can join other Bengalurians at Balabrooie (government guest house near Chitrakala Parishad) on 26th, please do lend the weight of your support to the protest against such criminal profligacy and anti-democratic moves.

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Similar Story

Bengaluru’s GBA and Hyderabad’s CURE: What they have in common and where they differ

While the mega-cities have split up into smaller corporations, both have put state leadership in control of city governance.

With the Core Urban Region (Integrated Governance) Bill 2026, better known as the CURE Bill passing in the Telangana Legislative Assembly, India's two fastest-growing mega-cities—both having crossed the 1.3-crore population mark—now operate under brand-new urban governance laws enacted within roughly two years of each other.  Both states confronted the exact same structural challenge: a single, overstretched corporation, fractured inter-agency coordination, and an urgent need for hyper-local administrative units capable of  delivering civic services efficiently. In an earlier article, we broke down how local governance would change with the Greater Bengaluru Governance Act. Read it here. Two mega-cities, one playbook The…

Similar Story

SIR in Bengaluru: Disenfranchisement at a grand scale

With Bengaluru Urban seeing a 42 per cent reduction in the voter rolls, is the SIR an update or a denial of electors' rights?

The CEO Karnataka recently published the final rolls for Karnataka after finishing their hurried and stressful Special Intensive Revision (SIR). People were asked to prove that they live where they do, and map themselves or their parents/ancestors to the 2002 voter roll. The final roll published now has 4.54 Crore electors in Karnataka as against the 5.54 Cr as per the 2025 Special Summary Review; a reduction of almost one crore electors or 18% of the earlier rolls. However, the numbers in the 28 constituencies in Bengaluru Urban paint a more drastic picture. The 1.026 crore electors as per the…