Millions of workers who did not demand wage!

The expense of composting Bangalore's wet waste shot through the roof, with the income not being able to match it. Then,"I began to recruit new staff; millions of them!"

Today KCDC has around 300 vermi-composting pits. Pic: Nikita Malusare

I had ended my first blog on garbage (you can read this blog here) with the observation that the Karnataka Compost Development Corporation was not making a great deal of money from the business of producing compost from city garbage, even though we had a long waiting list of satisfied customers and no marketing problem on our hand.

We had two problems with compost production. The first was that in a city that produced plenty of garbage – it was estimated to be around 1,000 tons per day then and is said to be closer to 4,500 tonnes now – there was a real shortage of good unadulterated organic garbage. As I related in my previous blog, I needed pure green waste unsullied by paper, plastic, soil and metal. We often did not have access to adequate quantities of that kind of garbage; most of it was purchased by farmers directly from the city vegetable market where it was available in abundance, and was taken away to compost pits in villages surrounding Bangalore.

This was a flourishing business. The city sanitary staff was bribed by privateers to divert good garbage away from us. We got the garbage nobody wanted, full of paper, plastic, metal and worse. This slowed down composting and increased the cost of processing, which comprised of various shakers, sieves and magnets that separated composted organic material from inert or noxious waste.

The second problem I faced was the necessity to constantly tend to my rotting piles of garbage. Any good organic gardener will tell you that good composting requires turning around garbage periodically to aerate it. That is easy to do at a small scale, but in my composting yard, I had a few earth movers working round the clock to turn over piles of garbage. I was burning up a lot of diesel in the process, which not only created more pollution at my work site, but added to my costs as well.

Then I began to recruit new staff; millions of them.

Millions of workers who did not demand a wage

My saviour appeared in the form of Eudrilus eugeniae, an earthworm species noted for their ability to chomp through compost and produce manure. After a consultation with the University of Agricultural sciences in Bangalore, we started a vermicomposting yard.

The purest of our garbage was moved under cover – coconut leaf thatched sheds were more than enough for our purpose – and our new recruits were unleashed on our compost, now neatly arranged in long, stone-lined troughs. They needed no goading to get to work. Each worm is a miniature composting tube, consuming about five times its body weight every day, to produce dark worm castings, rich in nutrients.

Eudrilus eugeniae multiplied like rabbits – I know I am mixing metaphors here – worked on Saturdays and Sundays and did not demand pay hikes. They also put my earth movers out of business. Each worm came up to the top of the pile to deposit its castings and all we needed to do was to collect these on a weekly basis. When they exhausted a pile, they moved on to the next pile that was prepared in advance for their arrival, through a gate that would be opened between two troughs. In other words, they moved on their own; I did not have to pay them a transfer allowance either.

We began to make a profit, as our production costs dropped and we began to produce higher value vermicompost.

However, the voracious appetites of our worms threw up another challenge. We were unable to provide enough pure garbage for these greedy fellows. If we fed them the usual rubbish supplied by the city garbage trucks – mixed with grit, plastic and paper, our worms would sulk, hang around in rowdy groups and parade around with placards reading, ‘Down down! Management’.

Why not we buy good garbage? I thought. After all, if segregated green waste is what we desperately want, we could actually put a value on such waste and buy it; that would mean that we also share our profits with those households that segregate garbage.

City Corporation refuses to buy back manure

We made presentations to our shareholders, which included the Bangalore City Corporation as well. Our deal was that we would be willing to share our profits with a group of citizens in any part of the city, if they were able to supply segregated green waste. I thought we might have a good thing going here, because there were many groups that were interested in segregating, but who lost their way because they had no land locally available for undertaking decentralized composting. Our arrangement would result in winners all around. Households who segregated garbage would get paid for their effort, we could get good garbage and our worms would happily begin to feast again.

Sadly, the idea did not sell well. Our presentations were not glossy enough for the City Corporation. They were enamoured of private business interests that blew them away with promises of magical imported technology that would make all their garbage worries disappear overnight.

Worse, we could not even get the City Corporation to buy back our vermi-compost for their parks and gardens. Instead, the Corporation continued to spend considerable money buying so called manure from private producers.

I say, ‘so called,’ for a reason. We obtained a sack of manure purchased by the City Corporation Horticultural Office and tested it for its nutritive value.

It turned out to be half-burnt coconut husk; comprising of nothing but inert cellulose fibres.

This was originally published on Raghunandan’s blog in Accountability India, and has been republished by Citizen Matters with his permission.

Related Articles

The story of the first composting plant in Bengaluru


  1. Dinesh Rao says:

    Mr.Raghunandan, your article is informative and motivating at the same time. I can vouch on the benefits of vermi-composting and to my mind it has the potential to address the social and ecological issues associated to garbage collection and disposal.

    At my house, have a vermi-composting bin measuring 4 ft X 1 ft X 1.5 ft for last 8 months. All wet waste (veg / fruit peels, food left overs including bones of chicken / fish etc) goes into the bin and in a matter of 3-4 days is converted into odour-less, nutrition rich compost. We use this black-gold to grow veggies in containers and in a small patch of land. Veggies and greens seem to just love this manure and grow very well.

    In your article you have mentioned about the challenge of getting ‘good / segregated’ waste for vermi-composting. As a suggestion, what if the vermi-composting happens at source of waste generation itself ? What if there is a small composting appliance for each house and the wet waste is continuously converted into vermi-compost which can be bought for a price from the house hold ? Something similar to buying old news papers from households.

    Also, vermi-composting reduces the amount of waste to almost 1/15th the initial weight. That is 15 kgs of wet waste gets reduced to about 1 kg of vermi-compost. This is like reducing 1 full truck load of wet waste to about 10 bags of fine vermi-compost which can be carried in a small mini-van or even the boot of a car.

    Would like to hear your views on this and may be start a pilot project in a neighbour-hood to look at feasibility of large scale implementation.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Similar Story

Living along a drain: How Delhi’s housing crisis aggravates environmental hazards

The lack of affordable housing for the urban poor living on the streets of East Delhi creates a host of challenges including environmental ones.

Sujanbai, 46, has been living in Anna Nagar in East Delhi for over six years now, earning her living as a street vendor of seasonal fruits. And yet she laments, "There is no space to live in this Dilli. Not even on the footpath. The police come and shunt you out. This is the only space along the nalla (open drain) where I’m able to put a cot for my family to lie on." This space that Sujanbai refers to is the site of a settlement, perched on the ridge of a nalla or drain in Anna Nagar. This was…

Similar Story

Citizens demand consultation for BDA redevelopment, say environmental hazards ignored

Residents say they don't mind redevelopment but it must be done after public consultations and not in violation of the BDA Charter.

The recent approval for revamping seven Bangalore Development Authority (BDA) complexes into retail, multiplex, entertainment centres and offices has not been well received by citizens. Residents say there have been no public consultations and a total lack of transparency. Sneha Nandihal, founder of I Change Indiranagar, says the Detailed Project Report (DPR) is not available in the public domain. "We filed an RTI but received a convoluted response, so we obtained it from other sources." Ajay Reddy, member of third block Koramangala RWA, says the biggest issue is that no public consultation has been done so far: ”We don't mind redevelopment…