Nothing concrete on commuter rail: Bengalureans unhappy with rail budget

The suburban rail for Bengaluru got a mention in the rail budget speech. However activists say that’s not enough.

With increased burden on roads, Bengaluru needs suburban trains to decongest the city. Pic: Shree D N

Bengaluru’s suburban railway got a one-line mention in Railway Minister Suresh Prabhu’s speech on Railway Budget 2016-17. “Bengaluru, the technology hub of the country, warrants a comprehensive suburban system. We will partner with State Government in this endeavour,” he said while presenting railway budget, in the Loksabha on February 25, 2016.

Assurances on commuter railway are not new to Bangaloreans. The railway budget speech by Mamata Banerjee In 2010-11 mentions about partnering with the states for improving the suburban railway system. Chief Minister Siddaramaiah announced the formation of Bangalore Suburban Rail Corporation Limited in his budget speech for 2013.

The budget speech given by D V Sadananda Gowda in 2014 Railway Budget had also talked about boosting suburban railway.

“Bengaluru with bustling business activity attracts large commuters from surrounding rural  areas and towns necessitating better connectivity of Bengaluru City with its suburban areas and hinterland. Study to explore the possibility of enhancing the existing IR network of Bengaluru for meeting the above need will be taken up. In addition, to cater to the demand of Passenger Traffic in Bengaluru area, Byappanahalli will be developed as a coaching terminal,” said Gowda. He also promised many new routes and extra existing trains in existing routes that criss-cross Bengaluru.

Campaigns for Namma Railu from Bengaluru

This article and this article describe the journey of commuter railway in Bengaluru. The citizens and the government have been pushing for local trains in Bengaluru since 2010. Ahead of Railway Budget 2016-17, Bengalureans started campaigning for the suburban railways through social media, emails and meetings. Members of the group Bengaluru Suburban Train Passengers’ Association even started a hunger strike.

This Citizen Matters article helped citizens support the campaign and reach out to the Railway authorities through emails and social media. There were more than 100 emails that went to the railway ministry as a result of this campaign.

Finally the suburban cause got only one-line mention of the much-awaited consent from the Indian Railways to partner with the state government, which is exactly where the issue has been stuck for sometime now. What do the citizens who campaigned for the cause feel about the issue?

‘Very disappointed’

“Very disappointed to say the least. I had hoped that this year railway budget will show the intent for Bengaluru Suburban Rail Project by giving the necessary approval and the necessary budget allocation. Both are missing in the budget except for a mention of it, which is nothing new,” says Khader B Syed, an activist in Namma Railu team.

“This time around, many people had put in lot efforts in reaching out to the Union Ministers from Karnataka, Bengaluru development Ministers, Chief Minister and the Railway Minister to get some traction, but seems it didn’t had the desired impact,” Syed says. He adds that the Suburban Rail project has not yet achieved the prominence inside the government corridors, and there is a lot of opposition to Suburban Rail Project both inside and outside the government.

“Going forward, we need to double the advocacy efforts for creating more awareness among the public and need to look at the PIL option as well,” he feels.

“Clarity is required for Bengaluru suburban rail, on the percentage of investment and fund allocation,” says Sanjeev Dyamannavar, another activist from Namma Railu team.

“Quite disappointed that there’s only a cursory mention of ‘Bangalore Commuter Rail’ in the Rail budget,” says Muralidhar Rao, a member of Praja-RAAG group that has created Namma Railu team. “The importance of the scheme as the most cost-effective way of decongesting the city, by allowing the growth to spread to the townships around it, doesn’t appear to have dawned on the powers that be, either at the centre or even the state,” he adds.

“Unfortunate to see the Commuter Rail System for Bengaluru getting stuck in the logjam between State government and Indian Railways… Hopefully the State Government and Indian Railways will get the commuter rail going in the right earnest to help decongest Namma Bengaluru,” says Sridhar Pabbisetty, CEO of Namma Bengaluru Foundation.

‘Loss to exchequer by transport issues underestimated’

“We urge the SWR, Railway Board, State and the Central Govt’s to iron out the details quickly and get the trains up and running in a phased and time bound manner,” says Elangovan Kulandaivelu, a Whitefield resident.

Anjali Saini, another resident of Whitefield and a Whitefield Rising activist, feels that the rail budget allocation for Bangalore was disappointing. “There is no firm execution plan that has been shared. The Government needs to show its intent by immediately utilising its share to implement the short term asks of Namma Railu/Praja to provide immediate relief to the commuting public,” she adds.

“The budget does not recognize the importance of the IT capital’s need for commuting efficiencies and under-estimates the loss to the State exchequer and the nation,” she says.

Related Articles

Land for Namma Railu: Incentivise participation of land-owners
Commuter rail plans going nowhere?
Rajeev Gowda asks Sadananda Gowda to speed up Bengaluru Commuter Rail
I will speed up Metro and bring commuter rail to Bengaluru: Nandan Nilekani
Commuter rail: Just a few miles more to start
Commuter Rail to be a reality in Bangalore: CM
Four reasons behind Siddaramaiah govt’s failure to get Commuter Rail to city
Chief Minister Siddaramaiah writes to MPs and Ministers on commuter railway
Sadananda Gowda gifts more trains to Bengaluru, to boost suburban network
Funding Bengaluru’s Suburban Railways: PPP, or public funds?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Similar Story

Scenes from a community walk in Mumbai

When I moved to Mumbai, the city felt extremely 'walkable,' but a walking tour in Dadar broadened my definition of walkability.

When I moved to Mumbai in June 2023 for work, I found myself going for sight seeing to the city's tourist destinations. Though the city appeared to have consistent and wide footpaths almost everywhere, vehicular right of way seemed to be prioritised over the pedestrian right of way. This struck me as very strange, even as I continued to enjoy walking through lanes of Mumbai very much. On one hand, there is excellent footpath coverage, utilised by large crowds everywhere. On the other hand, speeding vehicles create obstacles for something as simple as crossing the road.  "Though Mumbai appeared to…

Similar Story

Marooned and abandoned: Study reveals displaced families were put in the path of floods

Perumbakkam in Chennai has faced floods in 2015, 2018, 2019, 2020, 2021 and 2023. Despite that, 12,045 families were resettled there since 2015.

When Cyclone Michaung-induced floods hit the resettlement colonies of Perumbakkam, the houses on the ground floor were quickly inundated. On a priority basis, persons with disabilities were allocated houses on the ground floor. However, with the floods, their vulnerability pushed them further to the fringes. They were forced to climb stairs seeking refuge in other people's homes that already had leaky roofs and damp walls. This was not the first time people in resettlement colonies in Perumbakkam or Semmencherry were facing floods. Almost every year, November and December are months of struggle for the families, who are evicted and resettled…