Large scale changes in voter list: Is the CEO concerned?

The CEO of Karnataka disagreed with allegations that 30% of voter names were removed from the rolls in Basavanagudi. He is right - the deletions were close to 36.36%. He said "over 53,000 names" were added to the rolls - right again! 3,99,299 voters were added.

Lakhs of names have been reported deleted from Bengaluru’s voter lists – there is even a PIL requesting the High Court to intervene. Shantala Damle, a social activist, was shocked to see over 30% names deleted from Basvanagudi constituency. (Ref: ToI, November 9th)

In his response, the Chief Electoral Officer, Karnataka, said:

"I disagree with the claims of 30% deletions. A revision exercise was done, but there was no erratic deletion. Booth level officers of BBMP have visited individual houses. In April-July 2012, over 53,000 names were added after BBMP realised that genuine voters were affected in some places. If there are any deletions , BBMP has to look in to it"

The CEO is right. Deletions in Basvanagudi constituency between April to November this year were not 30%. They were 36.36%! In April 2012, Basvanagudi constituency had 2,34,308 voters, of which 69,875 voters were deleted in July. The count has reduced by another 15,312 voters in November. The deletions since April this year till now is at least 85,187 voters. It is 36.36% of the voters we had in April.

The CEO has stated that the deletions were not 30% but not how much it is.  Is he concerned?

If the deletions were ‘not erratic’, were they done with a design to erase some non-professional records created by his organisation?

However, lakhs of absurd records remain in the rolls. You look for one error, you find a dozen.

CEO has stated that over 53,000 names were added in April – July 2012. He is right again. 3,99,299 voters were added as per the lists he published on his website, which is over 53,000, 7.53 times.

Why is he saying ‘over 53,000’ and not ‘about 4,00,000’? In more than 50% of booths, additions are more than 4%, which require him to cross-verify additions. Neither deletions nor additions were verified. Is the CEO concerned about the large number of additions?

The CEO states, "If there are any deletions, BBMP has to look into this." Is he not interested to look in to the problems when we have been reporting specific errors for the past five months?

Hand Book for Electoral Registration Officers published by EC in 2009 (available on CEO’s website) states:

"Under Section 13 AA of the Representation of the People Act, 1950, there shall be a Chief Electoral Officer (CEO) for each State/Union Territory … the Chief Electoral Officer shall supervise the preparation and revision of electoral rolls of all the constituencies in the State."

If CEO takes services of BBMP to maintain the electoral rolls, he cannot disown accountability. Passing orders and giving directives is a responsible activity – it is not an escape from accountability.

BBMP South and BBMP North officers say that there are no Booth Level Officers (BLOs). CEO tells the press that BLOs have visited individual houses. How can non-existent people visit houses?

EC Letter No. 23/1/2012-ERS Dated: 26th September, 2012 states "Name, phone number of every BLO should be put on the website of the concerned CEO." The list of BLOs neither available on CEO’s website nor BBMP offices. The BLOs don’t exist.

Should we interpret the phrase ‘concerned CEO’ as a CEO without any concern about his responsibilities?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Similar Story

Children in North Chennai keep local democracy alive through Bala Sabhas

Child councillors push for change in Chennai by bringing attention to crucial issues like drug addiction.

“A democracy masterclass is brewing in North Chennai, where children are showing the way for the 200 ward councillors of the Greater Chennai Corporation,” says Charu Govindan, Founder and Convener at Voice of People. For around six years, her collective has advocated for Area Sabhas, which many councillors conveniently skip to avoid meeting the residents.  But Bala Sabhas, led by child councillors in North Chennai for over a year, are pushing for real change. They have prompted the installation of new street lights and barbed wire fencing at a local GCC school in Tondiarpet, for example.  What is a Bala…

Similar Story

Comprehensive plan in place to minimise environmental impact of Namma Metro construction: BMRCL

Following Citizen Matters' article on Namma Metro construction and its effects on air quality, BMRCL responds.

At Citizen Matters, we recently published an article by our reporter Gangadharan B, addressing the increased dust pollution caused by Namma Metro construction in Bengaluru. The report explored how certain mitigation measures are not being followed at Namma Metro construction sites, affecting air quality and taking a toll on public health. The report also raised questions on whether the air quality in the construction sites is monitored regularly as per the suggestions of the Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) report. While multiple attempts were made to reach out to Bengaluru Metro Rail Construction Limited (BMRCL) before publishing the article, we did…