Nobel laureate, supporter of Bengaluru’s lake revival, passes away

Such was her connection to Bangalore that she had been herself studying lakes in the city for the last year or so and had deep insights into the way forward for citizen action on lake preservation.

Prof. Elinor Ostrom, recipient of the 2009 Nobel Prize for Economics, passed away in Indiana, United States, on 12th June, after a short and intense battle with pancreatic cancer. Her life and her ideas hold deep significance for us in Bangalore.

Prof. Ostrom visiting Kaikondanahalli lake in February 2012. Pic: Harini Nagendra

In February 2012, Prof. Ostrom visited Bangalore for a few days, giving the T N Khoshoo Memorial Lecture at the Ashoka Trust for Research in Ecology and the Environment (ATREE). In addition, she was very keen to visit one of the sites of a recent research program that she and I had initiated last year to examine collective action and lake restoration in Bangalore.

Kaikondrahalli lake on Sarjapur road, which was recently restored through a collaborative effort by local communities and the BBMP, was one of the sites of this research, and she had heard much about this lake through the years that we have been working on it.

The lake community had gathered in full force to meet her on the morning of the 3rd of February 2012. She was 78 years old, had just got off a long plane ride and completed an intense three day visit to Delhi, and was even then battling cancer. Her energy and drive could always put people much younger and fitter to shame, however, and she enthusiastically undertook a trip around the lake boundary, asking many questions of the lake community, and suggesting to them that they invest in long term monitoring of the ecological condition of the lake, so that research and practice could go hand in hand.

She planted a jackfruit sapling – which is growing very well at the edge of the lake – and was very happy at the choice of species, commenting that as a girl she had a jackfruit tree in her garden in Los Angeles, and knew the tree well.

Elinor Ostrom planting a sapling at Kaikondrahalli lake in February 2012. File pic: Priya Ramasubban.

Internationally renowned for her research on the collective management of commons, Prof. Ostrom’s research has demonstrated the capacity for local communities to organise to protect shared natural resources – called common property – such as lakes, forests, grazing lands and fisheries. She and her colleagues systematically collected evidence that proved the potential for sustainable and equitable governance of natural resources in a manner where responsibilities and benefits were shared by all.

This line of thought went quite contrary to the opinion of many governments and conservation agencies, who assumed that local communities could only be capable of destroying their environment, and needed a benevolent dictatorial government to deal out rules and judgement from above. Lin – as she was popularly known – worked with colleagues across the world and drew on case studies from places as diverse as Nepal, Kenya Los Angeles, and Switzerland to develop a set of “design principles”, conditions under which local communities were more likely to be able to develop sustained, ecologically and socially relevant rules for management of their natural resources.

These design principles were rather simple, but very profound – for instance, one principle states that people are more likely to follow a set of rules if they have had some say in developing these rules themselves, rather than having rules given to them by someone else (say the government) and being told they had to follow them.

Another important design principle is that monitoring – and sanctioning of offenders through fines and punishments – is essential for protecting natural resources. Otherwise, one selfish individual can disrupt the entire effort of the group, and as she put it so eloquently “human beings don’t like to be ‘suckers’!”

Unfortunately, just a few months after her visit to Bangalore, this intellectual giant – who was also one of the most generous, open hearted and kindest of people – passed away. This is a sad and irreplaceable loss – definitely so for all those who knew her, but also those who did not. Her ideas have transformed the world and pointed to alternate, socially just and ecologically sustainable ways of governing our natural resources.

We have too few of our lakes, forests and fisheries left, and as she wrote in one of the last articles she published before she passed away, time is one of the scarcest resources at hand. She used the time she had well, writing emails, reviewing papers and composing letters of recommendation even from hospital in the last few weeks. This included sending a letter of recommendation to the UN commending the work of the Environment Support Group for utilising legal redressal mechanisms towards lake protection in Bangalore.

Our city was close to her heart, and she greatly enjoyed and often reminisced about her two brief visits to Bangalore – one personal visit in October 2008, and her second, more recent visit in February this year. She had read a lot about ecological and social transformations in Bangalore, and was looking forward to the next stages of a long term research project that we had started last year, examining collective action and conservation in the lakes of Bangalore.

Unfortunately, this was not to be so, although she was able to leave behind a solid foundation for this research. We are truly fortunate to have lived in a world touched and transformed by her ideas and ideals.

Visitors at Kaikondanahalli lake stop to see the jackfruit tree that Prof. Ostrom planted, and read about her work on community conservation. Pic: Harini Nagendra

One of the last articles she wrote focused on the need to look beyond international agreements at the Rio +20 summit and incorporate the diversity of grassroots movements that are working across the world to mitigate some of the impacts of climate change. This article can be read at:

A short, succinct lecture that brings out many of her essential ideas on community management of commons, which also gives a great sense of her verve, energy, and personality, can also be viewed at:

And finally, for those interested in knowing more about her views on the way forward for governance of Bangalore’s lakes, here is a video of her T Khoshoo lecture in February where she discusses some of our lake research, illustrated with photographs from Kaikondanahalli,Varthur and Bellandur keres.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Similar Story

Smothered by smog: Struggle of vegetable vendors in Delhi’s Keshopur Mandi

Delhi's air pollution affects every resident, but for the urban poor, like vegetable vendors of Keshopur Mandi, it is much worse.

Halfway through our interview, vegetable vendor Rekha asked me point blank, “Isse kya hoga,” and at that moment, I could not think of an answer. She was right and had every reason to be hopeless. Much has been written about air pollution and much energy has been spent on expert committees and political debates and yet nothing has changed.  “Hum toh garib log hai, hum kisko jakar bole, hamari sunvai nahin hoti” (We are poor people, to whom do we go, nobody listens to us),” says Rekha Devi, who sells vegetables in the Keshopur Mandi. Keshopur is a large retail…

Similar Story

Study shows TNPCB ill-equipped to monitor the environmental impact of pollution

The scientific team of TNPCB is working at half its strength, affecting the Board's ability to carry out inspections in Chennai and other parts of the State.

The Central Pollution Control Board and the State Pollution Control Boards are the primary custodians for preventing and controlling all forms of pollution in our country. Despite their significant role in environmental protection, the public is mostly unaware of the functions of these regulatory bodies, due to insufficient research. Therefore, we at Citizen consumer & civic Action Group (CAG) have attempted to understand the functions of the Tamil Nadu Pollution Control Board (TNPCB), through a study titled ‘The Tamil Nadu Pollution Control Board in Retrospect: An Examination of Selected Parameters from 2017 to 2022.’ Read more: Fisherfolk lament as environmental…