Inflated Bengaluru budget may have Rs.5000 cr hole

Last year, BBMP projected an outlay of Rs.8400 crores, and garnered far less. A virtual action replay happened last week at the council for the 2011-12 budget.

In action replay of last year, BBMP has presented a massive budget outlay of Rs.9100 cr for the city on a base of unproven revenues and uncommitted grants.

BBMP Council’s budget session in progress on August 18th 2011. Pic: Navya P K.

Last year BBMP’s actual receipts were Rs 4930 cr lesser than the projected amount of Rs 8447 cr. This year, the gap may be bigger, with a seemingly impossible expectation of receipts of Rs 9112 cr. This, along with opening balance of Rs 85 cr, is expected to cover expenditure of Rs 9196 cr for 2011-12.

Reading out the budget at the Council meeting on August 18, G Manjunath Raju, Chairman of BBMP’s Taxation and Finance Committee, said that additional revenue of Rs 5595 cr will be realised through some new steps.

But many of these steps are the same that BBMP had proposed in last year’s budget, such as collecting higher property tax, auctioning of hoardings and widening the trade license fee net.

Infrastructure projects this year for Bengaluru

Widening of 10 roads
Mission road
Begur road
Tannery road
Bannerghatta road
Hennur ring road to Kannur ring road
Abbigere to Lakshmipura
Chikkabanavara to Ganigarahalli
Vidyaranyapura road
Halagevaderahalli to Pantarapalya
Thindlu road

Five grade separators
Banashankari temple and Ring Road junction
Sony World junction in Koramangala
Maramma Circle in Malleswaram
Chord road
Vatal Nagaraj road in Rajaji nagar

Seven underpasses
Jayanagar 5th block
JP Nagar 3rd and 4th phase
Hosur-Begur junction
Bhashyam circle-Sadashivanagar
Shivananda circle
Fountain circle-Okalipuram
Rani Chennamma circle

Property tax target same as last year

In fact, the target for property tax collection this year is the same as last year – Rs 1500 cr. In the last budget, property tax was projected to go up from Rs 795 cr to Rs 1501 cr. It was based on the premise that 4.6 lakh more properties will be identified through GIS and brought under tax net.

But overall, only Rs 894 cr was collected as property tax, says BBMP’s Action Taken Report (ATR) which was released along with the budget. Only 2.12 lakh new properties – less than half the target – were brought under the tax net, says the ATR.

BBMP’s justification for the same Rs 1500 cr target this year, is that all properties are under tax net now, and that commercial tax rates will be levied from unaided educational institutions, hospitals etc. For instance, BBMP plans to collect Rs 50 cr by levying three times property tax from vacant site owners for site cleaning.

Advertisement tax this year is projected to be Rs 150 cr. But only Rs 9 cr could be collected last year on a projected amount of Rs 100 cr. (This is because advertisement renewal was stopped by Commissioner’s order in July 2010 and the new advertisement policy was not enacted.)

Same is the case with trade license fee – it was supposed to go up from Rs 9 cr to Rs 107 cr last year, but BBMP collected only Rs 16 cr altogether. Yet, this year too BBMP has set its target high, at Rs 85 cr.

When asked how revenue targets will be met this financial year, Manjunath Raju does not have any clear answers. "There is change in policy with respect to property tax, optical fibre cables etc. It will get done; work will be carried on by the committee members who come into power next year. It is a continuing process."

Manjunath Raju, Chairman of BBMP’s Taxation and Finance Committee. Raju is councillor of Kadu Malleshwara Ward. Pic: Navya P K.

The one change this year is that the BBMP has given up hopes of revenues from the Sakrama (regularisation of building violations) settlement. Sakrama has not been included in the receipts this year. Last year, BBMP ambitiously estimated Rs 750 cr from Sakrama even as the Sakrama Bill itself had not been passed.

Amidst all, a new ambitious revenue component added this year is collection of Rs 780 cr from telecom companies which run their optical fibre cables underground or through Storm Water Drains (SWDs).

Projecting receipts from non-existent state govt grants

BBMP has also inflated its sources of money from government grants. This year, it shows the state government granting Rs 2300 cr, even though only Rs 250 cr has been allocated so far. This allocation was done in state government budget earlier this year.

More than Rs 2000 cr is yet to be granted, but this amount is included already in receipts. Of this amount, Rs 602 cr is expected as grants under 13th Finance Commission and State Finance Commission (SFC). In addition to salaries and some administrative expenses of BBMP, these funds are also allocated for works on roads, parking, SWM etc.

"Finance Commission grants are given annually, but state government can decide on the amounts; it does not have to give the amount specified in the budget," says a highly placed official in BBMP’s Accounts department, on condition of anonymity.

Rs 1500 cr has been included as special development grants, which is up to the state government to decide on. Last year Rs 1300 cr was requested under this head, but only Rs 300 cr was granted.

"BBMP has requested a total of Rs 3000 cr from state government, including the Finance Commission funds. The draft budget is only an estimate; it has to be passed by BBMP Council and state government. So the budget will keep getting revised depending on fund receipt, but usually the draft budget gets passed without many changes," says the BBMP official.

Defending his committee’s projection on grants, Raju, however, says, "Unlike last year, we had a series of meetings with the government already and are sure of getting the funds." When asked which projects would get affected in case of lack of state funding, Raju says that the committee has not thought about it yet.

He says that there is no priority in terms of the projects in general either. "We have given funds to all departments. The Commissioner will decide on which projects should be prioritised. Our focus is only on getting the receipts."

JNNURM grant funds of Rs 216 cr will be used for storm water drain (SWD) works, flyover and underpass constructions, etc.

Grants apart, borrowing this year will be Rs 1065 cr, from HUDCO and other agencies.

On monitoring of projects during implementation, Raju says that the concerned Standing Committees (SCs) can audit them, and that Taxation and Finance Committee can only enquire to the SCs about project progress.

Infrastructure takes bulk of the expenditure plan 

Like last year’s budget, infrastructure works are given importance in this year’s budget too. Allocation for capital works has grown to 66% compared to last year’s 58%. Another 3% is for JNNURM projects. Allocation for health and education combined has gone down to 2% from 6% last year. Welfare is allocated 6%. Administration, maintenance, etc., make up the remaining 23%.

In grant for each ward, 10% is reserved for Rain Water Harvesting (RWH), Rs 25 lakh is granted for dry waste segregation centre/ organic waste converter, and Rs 4 lakh is for medical grant for the needy. Funds for wards is the same as last year – Rs 2 cr for old wards and Rs 3 cr for new wards.

TDR bank proposed, size of BBMP zones to be rationalised

Expenditure highlights

» Road widening – Rs 55 cr
» Storm Water Drain remodelling (de-silting, covering and connecting drains in four valleys and CMC areas) – 419.63 cr
» Rain Water Harvesting – Rs 20 cr
» Sports – 81.53 cr
» Tree Parks – 10 cr
» Welfare (housing for SC/ST, EWS, medical kit for girl students, vocational training, medical insurance for 7 lakh marginalised families)- 791 cr » Lake development – Rs 121 cr
» Building hospitals and maternity homes – Rs 36.15 cr
» Building educational institutions – Rs 13.92 cr

Several new policy steps are evident in this budget. There is a proposal for a TDR bank wherein only BBMP can buy and sell TDR certificates. "BBMP will only be a nodal agency to facilitate TDR sale" says Raju.

Raju makes it clear that if sellers are demanding compensation BBMP will pay them. "For this we will tie-up with a bank to provide funds at low interest rates. We are not reserving any funds for TDR bank in budget," says Raju. "It will be done in exceptional cases where owners absolutely reject TDR and if road widening is inevitable", he adds.

Zones will be restructured for better administration. " Old zones have more than 50 wards while some new ones have only 8 wards or so. So all 198 wards should be distributed equally among the eight zones (around 25 wards per zone), so that officials’ work load will be even," says Raju.

A number of other projects planned include tree mapping, sapling plantation and introduction of cycle tracks. BBMP says it will also co-ordinate with IIM-B, IISc etc for starting a technical library. Mobile quality control labs for monitoring BBMP works are also on the cards. .

GIS being the flavour of the past few years, yet another project has been added this time: GIS-operated pothole filling machines. Raju says that he stumbled upon the idea on the Internet. No study has been done on this and procurement process has not been finalised. "Developed countries have this system where potholes are tracked through GIS and are filled evenly using machines. We are planning to install one such machine on pilot basis in each zone. It will be done extensively if the pilot is successful," he says.


  1. Vijay Krishnan says:

    The BBMP, most inefficient and corrupt of all the government bodies which have made the Bangaloreans life miserable. Read below…

    1.Drinking water is scarce in even the Municipal areas. Dependence on the ubiquitous water tanker in most areas is almost 70%. Many lakes have been encroached by builders of apartments and commercial complexes with the connivance of the City corporation leading to absence of the natural ground water recharging mechanism. This is a chicken and egg story…leads to more dependence on tanker water.

    2.Roads are in bad shape right within the city…leave alone the newly added areas of BBMP – the City Corporation.Every year contracts are awarded by the BBMP for giving a ‘make-up’ layer to the roads. Undoubtedly ample bribes are paid to get these contracts and come monsoon the roads get washed out. There’s a wonderful scientifically proven solution to double the longevity of the roads by adding recycled plastic to the roads and has been successfully adopted on some of Bangalore’s major roads (e.g Indiranagar 80ft road) . Sadly, the City Corporation is not actively promoting this for obvious reasons

    3.Garbage collection and disposal is a big scam in itself. City Corporation pays 160 crores a year to Contractors to collect and dispose garbage. Despite this most houses and apartments have to pay anywhere between Rs.100 to Rs.10,000 per month (for large apartments) for the garbage disposal. Even after all this money changing hands more than 80% of the garbage is unscientifically disposed in open landfills. The Pourakarmikas (City cleaning staff employed by via the contractors)are supposed to be paid Rs.120/- per day but the contractors pay them only Rs.40/- out of the Rs.80/- they get from the BBMP. Any guesses for where the rest of the money goes? And this year BBMP has imposed a Solid Waste Management Cess.

  2. Vijay Krishnan says:

    The recycling centers planned by the BBMP to be established in every ward at the cost of 25 lacs each is another sham. The pilot organic waste disposal plants established in Yelahanka is a failure with Electricity cost of the machine alone being around Rs.80,000/-. No guesses of what will befall this grandiose plan for setting up these waste collection centers.
    Instead the BBMP can well promote NGO’s and RWA’s who’re already involved in this to promote waste segregation and tie up with local scarp dealers for proper recycling of dry-waste collected.

    visit Renaisance Park in Malleshwaram for a good lesson on very cost effective waste-management for residences.

  3. Janardhan M says:

    Thanks for sharing the grateful information. I regularly visit your website to get information. Pre Launch Apartments in Electronic City Bangalore #Triaxiscolonnades #Pragathiamber

    Apartments in electronic city

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Similar Story

The trials of a school in Northeast Delhi in the aftermath of the 2020 riots

Rioters had left the Arun Modern Senior Secondary Public School in shambles in 2020. Here's the tale of its journey from then to now.

Kakul Sharma was in class 8 in 2020 when the Delhi riots occurred. Although she was safe at home, her school was attacked by a mob. "I thought I would never be able to go back to school. We believed that the world was ending. My sister cried all day when she saw a news channel telecasting the rubble of our school.” For the children of Northeast Delhi, like Kakul, the riot meant a school blackened by smoke, a charred library, broken benches, and a playground that looked like it was hit by a tornado. This was the shape in…

Similar Story

Push government to implement all welfare measures in Street Vendors Act : Lekha Adavi

Lekha Adavi, a member of AICTU, says that without BBMP elections, there are no corporators to address the issues of street vendors.

(In part 1 of the interview series, Lekha Adavi, member of the All India Centre of Trade Unions (AICTU), spoke about the effects of climate change on Bengaluru’s street vendors. In part 2, she highlights how The Street Vendors Act (Protection of Livelihood and Regulation of street vending) 2014 falls short in its implementation) Excerpts: How do you engage with local authorities or municipal agencies to raise awareness of the challenges faced by street vendors during temperature surges? What responses or support do they provide? Lekha: Well, they don't respond to any of our demands. In Bengaluru, the BBMP elections…