When can the cops catch you?

Did I have to pay the fine? Could the police have seized my bike?

I met with an incident recently (13th April 2008).

I was riding the bike from RT Nagar, I had to go over the Mekhri circle flyover to take a right from Hebbal road to turn towards IISC road. I turned right while the signal was changing from green to orange.I did not want to stop abruptly and since orange light is meant as a warning, I continued driving. If I had applied a sudden break, the auto right behind me may have hit me.

A police constable jumped in front of me from the side of the road asking me to stop. I stopped and took all my documents assuming he wanted to verify my documents.

He asked me to pay a fine saying I jumped the signal. On explaining that I did not jump the signal and when I crossed it was orange, he asked me questions like ‘Which country are you from?, Do you know the meaning of orange light? Are you an idiot?… You can show your intelligence in the court…’ and started behaving arrogantly.

I answered all his questions properly. I also pointed to him that he had been standing perpendicular to the signal light, he may not have noticed the signal.I said I was very confident that I had not jumped the signal. He threatened me saying I can show my intelligence in arguing the case in the court and he will book a case. He said he will try to put all evidence against me including the camera.

I said I was sure the camera evidence will prove that I was not at fault. He threatened me saying that my vehicle will be seized and will be released only after the case is resolved in the court. So I asked if it’s compulsory for my vehicle to be seized even if I am going to appear in the court for the case.

Instead of answering he started shouting and raising his hands and stepped closer. It looked like he was going to hit me. So I just paid the fine and left the place.

At the same time, while I was conversing with this police officer, his colleague, a police constable, tried to jump in front of another auto. The auto driver applied a sudden break. A bike which was closely following this auto hit the auto. The bike driver and his wife on the pillion fell down and got injured.

Now I’d like to ask readers:
1. Are police officers authorized to seize the vehicle in such situations?
2. Under what conditions can a police officer seize the vehicle?
3. How does one handle such cases when the citizen is strong and does not hesitate to go the court, but want to avoid the inconvenience of his vehicle getting seized until court case is resolved and bike returned back to the citizen?

Comments:

  1. Raghu Raju says:

    I agree with Praveen Kumar and i would also like to know about the above mentioned situations. Is there any mobile court or something to help us, if we get under these kind of circumstances? As i heard from others, there is nothing that could help you faster when u were caught by Police (traffic). Also , none knows the clear picture of how and when can a traffic police sieze your vehicle/documents/D.L.
    If there is anyone with the needed knowledge could help us, it would be of a great help not only to us but also to other co-citizens.

    Thanks in advance for your help!!!!

  2. rajesh says:

    Atleast one should be happy they are not asking bribes and instead give receipt for the fine.
    I also heard that some duplicate receipt books are floating around, but I could not verify such claims. any idea how to find ?

  3. Deepa Mohan says:

    citizens feel helpless during such incidents as there seems to be no way of appealing or disagreeing with the police; they seem to lay down the law, often arbitrarily.

    It would help if the police had a grievance cell; but I suppose, in no time, this would be mired in red tape and form-filling.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Similar Story

Maharashtra elections 2024: What do political parties promise for Mumbai in their manifestos?

Political parties have tried hard to woo their voters before assembly elections. We analyse their manifestos ahead of voting on November 20.

The 2024 Maharashtra election is not just a crucial determiner for the State but also for Mumbai. This is because it comes at a time when the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC) has been disbanded, leaving citizens without corporators to represent their concerns for the past two years. With no local representation, it isn't surprising that many candidates have released their individual manifestos, outlining the work they plan to undertake in their constituencies within the city. But do these manifestos address the challenges Mumbai is facing right now? The city has been struggling with a myriad of issues — huge gaps…

Similar Story

Mumbai voters, check out the candidates from your constituency

As Mumbai prepares to vote on November 20th, a handy list of all the city constituencies and candidate profiles in each of these

Table of contentsName of constituency: Borivali (AC 152)Incumbent MLA : Sunil Dattatraya Rane (BJP)2019 resultsConstituency summaryContesting candidates in 2024Name of constituency: Dahisar (AC 153)Incumbent MLA: Chaudhary Manisha Ashok (BJP)2019 resultsConstituency SummaryContesting candidates in 2024Name of constituency: Magathane (154)Constituency analysisIncumbent MLA: Prakash Rajaram Surve (SHS)2019 results:Contesting candidates in 2024Name of constituency: Mulund (155) Constituency analysis Incumbent MLA: Mihir Kotecha (BJP)2019 results: Contesting candidates in 2024Name of constituency: Vikhroli (156)Constituency analysis Incumbent MLA: Sunil Raut (SHS)2019 results:Contesting candidates in 2024Name of constituency: Bhandup West (157)Constituency Analysis Incumbent MLA: Ramesh Gajanan Korgaonkar (SHS)2019 results:Contesting candidates in 2024Name of constituency: Jogeshwari East (158) Constituency analysisIncumbent MLA:  Ravindra Dattaram Waikar (SHS)2019…