There has been a strange silence, both before and after the Janata curfew. Even as the rest of the world announces massive economic relief packages to tackle the Corona spread and help those whose livelihoods have been badly hit by the virus, the Narendra Modi government has said and done little on this so far. Trade unions and other groups have sent numerous recommendations to the Centre on steps that can be taken in the short term But even the economic task force, which the PM had announced during his address to the nation, has so far not yet been formed with the finance ministry passing the buck on this to the PMO.
States are left, for now, to fend for themselves with funds they can raise on their own. But GST has severely curtailed states’ ability to raise money from additional local taxation on goods and services. Kerala and West Bengal are the only states so far to have announced some relief measures.
In every city, concern is particularly high on the plight of daily wage and other informal economy workers like domestic help whose income has suddenly dried up. With all the metros in total lockdown, the plight of these workers is being highlighted by various groups. But there has not been a peep from the Centre so far on how they plan to face the economic fallout of the virus outbreak.
Citizen Matters spoke to two experts on the immediate short term steps the government can take. P Sivaram, a finance professional and former CFO and Vice President at Punjab Tractors till he launched a partnership firm that specialises in investing in growth and turnaround situations. And Devinder Sharma, agricultural economist and food policy analyst. These are their recommendations:
- First, treat this corona virus as a national emergency and apply the Defense of India rules. These rules enable the government to declare an emergency situation, under with fundamental rights are suspended and all other activity regulated.
- Prepare for a disaster model for at least the first quarter of the coming financial year. Like the National Disaster Management Authority, this model lays down the policies, plans and guidelines for disaster management and works to ensure timely and effective response to disaster, in coordination with similar bodies at the states, and allocates needed funds. Let’s say in our case, the most affected 60-75 locations may need different, stringent treatment.
- Import medical goods as needed regardless of costs
- Fine all PAN CARD holders for socialising despite orders
- Start a National Defence Fund like was done in 1962 and 1965 wars with Pakistan
- Differentiate between rural and urban. Rural banks , for example, are difficult to acess and ATMs are minimal. So rural areas could have a mix of goods–say food, other supplies– and cash transfer, on a 2 month basis whereas urban it could be all cash transfer.
- Transfer cash and goods to the unorganized workers and rural poor, for about 2-3 months in one go
- Insist on wage payments by MSMEs while deferring their payments of loans, statutory dues by a quarter through a special dispensation from the banks via RBI
- Need-based partnership between states and the Centre on health care and delivery of economic relief. Like percentage of share of cost estimates can be agreed. Not to be left at babu levels but at CM level.
- Rope in a lead NGO in a state as the 3rd leg of this PPP.
- Govt could even consider special incentives to all essential service workers, using donations from people and using state relief funds.
- Get quick advice from behavioural economists in India and take inputs from people like Dr Manmohan Singh
- All this will increase fiscal deficit, but this about saving the country right now. So unmindful of deficit numbers, the government will have to resort to massive infrastructure development across the country soon after monsoons tocreate assets, johs and kick-start consumption. Otherwise social unrest and related costs can escalate. Inevitably, given the existing economic slowdown, the first quarter of the next fiscal year will see a recession. The infrastructure investment will help the economy to limp back up in the subsequent quarters.
Devinder Sharma calls this an existential crisis. His recommendations:
- India is lucky to have the huge food stocks which will ensure every Indian gets food.
- Since the government has all the data it needs—by way of Jandhan account numbers, Aadhaar data and technology at its command, Government must without delay make cash transfer of Rs 3000 into all the Jandhan accounts, and bank accounts of the farmers, daily wagers in the unorganized sector and migrant workers
- Triple the PM Kisan benefit from Rs 6000 a year to Rs 18000 a year, giving a monthly benefit of Rs1500
- Transfer cash to all the MNREGA workers who cannot work in the circumstances
- Defer or reverse the Finance Minister’s September 2019 proposals including slashing of corporate tax and use the funds – Rs 1.45 lakh crores –to pay those who are losing wages in the current scenario
- Transfer free rations to all the migrant labour, unorganized daily wagers and poor, for a month or two at a time
- Accept that the assiduously built up food procurement system should not be tinkered with or discontinued, given the current experience
- Review its disinvestment ideas given how useful Air India has been