Dear Prime Minister, do not use pakoda sellers as your excuse!

In the wake of the controversy over Prime Minister Narendra Modi's reference to the street pakoda seller as an employment statistic, the author takes up the cause of street vendors across the nation and voices their real concerns.

Mr. Prime Minister,

In a TV interview recently, you asserted that a person earning Rs. 200 a day selling pakodas is also an employed person. Many people took offence to this statement, claiming that your promise to generate 1 crore jobs is a hoax. While we appreciate the fact that you recognise street vending as an employment, the harsh realities under which street vendors carry out their livelihood has been lost in your statement.

Street vending is an independent and dignified profession. We are proud to be street vendors. However, we cannot take away the context in which we have become street vendors. It is out of distress of migrating to a city, of drought in villages, agricultural crisis reeling in this country, and more importantly for lack of employment options that we have resorted to street vending.

Moreover, education has become a costly affair for millions of people in the country. In fact, you are further distancing it from the people by decreasing the budget outlay for education, as was presented last week. The poor in this country cannot get an education, but there are no job options for those educated either. And even when we want to earn a decent livelihood of street vending, we face harassment and threats of evictions from various authorities on a daily basis.

Act has failed to protect street vendors

While the Street Vendors (Protection of Livelihoods and Regulating Street Vending) Act, 2014 was passed by the UPA-II Government, very few State Governments have actually implemented the legislation. The Act grants a right to livelihood to us street vendors, and is intended to provide solace to us from all the harassment. However, we continue to be left out of public spaces, police officers demand hafta, municipal authorities threaten to evict us, residents call us dirty, that we obstruct traffic, and other such unreasonable allegations are made against us.

It has been four years since the Act came into force, and four years since you have been the Prime Minister of India. If you thought this was an honorable profession, why do we continue to be perceived as nuisance?

The Lieutenant General of Delhi ordered massive evictions, in blatant violation of the 2014 Act. Why has no action been taken against any authority across the country for trying to evict vendors? What have you, Mr. Prime Minister, done for us street vendors?

FDI in retail: When you sat in opposition to the UPA Government, you vehemently opposed Foreign Direct Investments in Retail – against Walmart and Target entering our country. However, you have now approved 100 per cent in single brand retail. This will no doubt harm small businesses, including us street vendors.

Smart City: To add insult to injury, your ‘smart cities’ project is ensuring complete evictions of street vendors. This project is not only affecting our livelihood, but is taking away our right to shelter as well. Smart city has become synonymous with evictions of street vendors and slums. Your vision of development does not include us, sir. Instead, your policies are increasing the number of dispossessed people every day. There is no respite for us from poverty. So, where is our acche din?

Demonetisation and GST: When you demonetised the Rs. 500 and Rs. 1,000 currency notes, we the street vendors were the most affected. You want to make India cashless. Do you expect our customers to swipe money into our phones for a dozen banana? In addition to this, you’ve introduced GST. It is wiping out small businesses who source small items for us to sell.

Sir, we do not want a ‘Smart City’, we do not want a ‘Digital India’, we do not want ‘Make in India’ or your ‘Swachch Bharath’, if it doesn’t allow municipal workers, construction workers, slum dwellers, and street vendors to live with dignity. We want public education, public health system, and public housing! You are shirking your responsibility to provide us all of this and are instead privatizing our entitlements.

Yes, it is employment if a person sells pakoda on the streets. But, do not use us as an excuse for your inability to provide employment to the citizens of this country, and going back on your promise. On the contrary, we street vendors stand on our abilities and hard work.We will fight against anyone who takes away our rights!

[Note: This was issued by Bengaluru Jilla Beedi Vyaparigala Sanghatanegala Okkuta (Affiliated to AICCTU) and has been republished with minimal edits]

Comments:

  1. Super Bhakth says:

    Soldiers are dying on the border and you are worried about your stupid pakodas. Now be a good boy and stand up for the national anthem. BMKJ.

  2. Raman Muthuswamy says:

    Hats off to the Author(s)for this wonderful, a matter-of-fact statys of the STREET VENDORS who thru’ the sun-shine & rain serve their own clients, despite innumerable day-today problems, esp. the harassments by the Police. One should NOT–least of all–the Elected Reps, that too holding the Highest Office in the Country, should NEVER BELITTLE THEIR SERVICES to the fellow-humans !! My heartfelt sympathies to these hawkers–men & women–and they shd be allowed to carry on with their jobs with dignity & self-respect !!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Similar Story

Bengalureans’ tax outlay: Discover the amount you contribute

Busting the myth of the oft repeated notion that "only 3% of Indians are paying tax". The actual tax outlay is 60% - 70%.

As per a recent report, it was estimated that in 2021-22, only 3% of the population of India pays up to 10 lakh in taxes, alluding that the rest are dependent on this. This begs the following questions: Are you employed? Do you have a regular source of income? Do you pay income tax? Do you purchase provisions, clothing, household goods, eyewear, footwear, fashion accessories, vehicles, furniture, or services such as haircuts, or pay rent and EMIs? If you do any of the above, do you notice the GST charges on your purchases, along with other taxes like tolls, fuel…

Similar Story

BBMP budget 2024-25: Allocations and climate action plan in conflict

Over Rs 2,130 crore allocated for roads in BBMP Budget 2024-25 far surpasses the allocations for improving healthcare, education and welfare.

The BBMP budget 2024-25 seems to be full of measures that are contradictory, which also undermine the rule of law. It hopes to garner Rs. 1,000 crore by permitting additional floors on high-rises as ‘premium floor-area ratio (FAR)’, over and above what is permitted by law.  At the same time, the budget has reduced the penalty on property tax defaulters by which it will lose about Rs. 2,700 crore!  Both these measures modify existing laws in an arbitrary manner, conveying the impression that laws may exist on paper but can be allowed to be bypassed at the whims of the…