Why cities like Vengurla and Panchgani could be idols for our metros

CSE REPORT ON CITIES THAT SEGREGATE

Our work is to empower citizens, made possible by your donation. Click to Donate
A door-to-door garbage collection van from the city of Indore. Pic: TheodoreIndiana/Wikimedia Commons

With Urban India alone generating a gigantic 1.5 lakh metric tonnes per day of Municipal Solid Waste, waste management has grown to become a huge burden in urban India. Despite the existence of strong laws — Solid Waste Management (SWM) Rules, 2016 and Plastic Waste Management Rules, 2016 — cities are stuck at the implementation level.

Advertisement

Now, a new report shows that while smaller cities have done a good job of complying with the major clauses of key environmental legislation, larger cities including Bengaluru and New Delhi are yet to satisfy the basic mandate of waste management: source segregation, or in more elaborate terms, segregation of different types of waste at the point at which they are generated.

A detailed assessment by the Delhi-based Centre for Science and Technology (CSE) of 20 Indian cities, which are part of the Forum of Cities that Segregate (see box below), reveals that smaller cities such as Vengurla and Panchgani in Maharashtra, and a few mid-level cities such as Alappuzha and Thiruvananthapuram in Kerala have been the most consistent and successful in dealing with waste in eco-friendly ways.

CSE Launched the ‘Forum of Cities that Segregate‘ on December 12 2017, in order to push cities to adopt an effective waste management system.

The key objectives of the forum include developing a knowledge exchange platform for participating cities on solid waste management, training and capacity building on source segregation model, tracking and assessing the progress of cities and documentation of best practices.

The cities that are part of the Forum are:

  • Indore
  • Panchgani
  • Alappuzha
  • Bhopal
  • Greater Hyderabad
  • South Delhi Municipal Corporation
  • East Delhi Municipal Corporation
  • Thiruvananthapuram
  • Mysuru
  • Gaya
  • Imphal
  • Bobbili
  • Gangtok
  • Gurugram
  • Vengurla
  • Bengaluru
  • Muzaffarpur
  • Patna
  • Balaghat
  • Vaijapur

Based on the provisions of SWM rules, CSE included 13 parameters for the assessment of these cities, including segregation at source, collection, transportation, waste processing, adoption of decentralised systems and the inclusion of the informal sector. 

Getting the basics right

One of the key aspects of waste management is segregation at source. Waste should be segregated into three types – wet waste, recyclable waste and rejected waste.

Unfortunately, only four out of the 20 forum cities assessed in 2017-18 have a segregation rate of higher than 90 per cent — Indore in Madhya Pradesh, Panchgani and Vengurla in Maharashtra and Alappuzha in Kerala. 

In contrast, bigger cities such as East Delhi Municipal Corporation (EDMC), South Delhi Municipal Corporation (SDMC), Patna, Gaya, Imphal and Gurugram have segregation levels below 33 per cent.

It may be noted that Alappuzha municipality is among the earliest cities to have started pushing for source segregation since 2013. 

            Segregation                  Cities
>90 % Indore, Panchgani, Alappuzha, Vengurla
75-90% Thiruvananthapuram, Muzaffarpur, Mysuru, Gangtok
50-75% Bhopal, Bengaluru, Bobbili, Vaijapur
33-50% Greater Hyderabad, Balaghat
<33% SDMC, EDMC, Patna, Gaya, Imphal, Gurugram

Source: CSE

Read more on waste management in Alappuzha and Indore here.

A majority of the cities, have deployed casual workers for door-to-door collection of garbage (including non segregated) and transported it to the landfills. While cities such as Indore, Bhopal, SDMC, EDMC, Mysuru and Bobbili have compartmentalised GPS tagged vehicles for transportation, bigger cities such as Patna, Gaya, Bengaluru, Gangtok, Gurugram and Balaghat need to further invest in efficient transportation systems.

                Transportation                  Cities
>90 % Indore, Panchgani, Alappuzha, Bhopal, Greater Hyder- abad, SDMC, EDMC, Thiruvananthapuram, Mysuru, Imphal, Bobbili, Vengurla
75-90% Bengaluru, Patna, Gaya, Gangtok, Gurugram, Balaghat
50-75% Muzaffarpur, Vaijapur
33-50% None
<33% None

Source: CSE

Solid Waste Management Rules, 2016 emphasises decentralised waste processing, which means treating waste within the locality,  preventing transportation to dumpyards.  Thiruvananthapuram and Alappuzha have followed the rule book, as more than 50 per cent of households in the former compost waste at source.

In Alappuzha, the Municipal Council has been providing subsidies on technologies for installation of plants in households. Basic aerobic technologies such as Matka (pot), pit and pipe composting as well as potable biogas plants are promoted.

Improve waste processing

While wet waste can be processed by composting, to reduce the burden on the ever-mounting landfills, dry waste should be recycled. Indian cities, with an exception of a few, are yet to channelise the procedure.

                   Wet waste processing                  Cities
>90 % Indore, Mysuru, Alappuzha, Panchgani, Balaghat, Vengurla
75-90% Bengaluru, Greater Hyderabad, Thiruvananthapuram,Bobbili
50-75% Bhopal, SDMC, EDMC, Vaijapur 
33-50% Imphal, Gangtok
<33% Muzaffarpur, Patna, Gaya, Gurugram

Source: CSE

Indore leads the way in wet waste processing, as the idea of treating it at source is promoted by the civic body. In this commercial capital of Madhya Pradesh, composters have been  installed in markets to treat wet waste.  Besides Indore, Mysuru, Alappuzha, Panchgani, Balaghat and Vengurla have taken the SWM rules seriously to treat wet waste. Wet waste processing happens at the seven operational zero waste management units in Mysuru. In Alappuzha, the majority of wet waste processing is done in-situ.

Only four cities in the Forum have 90 per cent or higher dry waste processing — Panchgani, Vengurla, Indore, and Alappuzha. Dry waste is categorised into recyclables and non recyclables. It is sent to the processing units for shredding and reusing.

“Many forum cities have a mechanism for dry waste channelisation and processing, however, the scale is very small. This needs to be further up-scaled in a majority of the forum cities,” stated the CSE’s report.

                   Dry waste processing                  Cities
>90 % Indore, Alappuzha, Panchgani, Vengurla
75-90% Bobbili, Thiruvananthapuram
50-75% Mysuru, SDMC, Imphal, Gangtok, Balaghat, Bhopal
33-50% EDMC, Vaijapur
<33% Bengaluru, Muzaffarpur, Patna, Gaya, Gurugram, Greater Hyderabad

Source: CSE

E-waste management takes a backseat

Indore is the only forum city that has set up an efficient system for collection and processing of electronic waste, construction and demolition (C&D) waste and bio-medical waste. India is among the world’s largest consumer of mobile phones with 1.5 million tonnes of e-waste generated in 2015, mentioned a report in The Hindu.  

The pace at which Indian cities are embracing e-waste management is certainly not enough to deal with the mountains of such waste generated. While e-waste collection occurs in cities such as Indore, Alappuzha, Bhopal, Bengaluru, Mysuru, Gangtok, Gurugram and Balaghat, there are no comprehensive methods followed to process it, as per the E-waste (Management) Rules, 2016.

                              Cities
Common Bio-medical Waste Treatment Facility

 

Indore, Alappuzha, Bhopal, Bengaluru, Greater Hyderabad, Panchgani, SDMC, Muzaffarpur, Thiruvananthapuram, My- suru, Patna, Gaya, Gangtok, Gurugram, Vengurla, Vaijapur 
C&D processing  Indore, SDMC, EDMC
E-waste collection Indore, Alappuzha, Bhopal, Bengaluru, Mysuru, Gangtok, Gurugram, Balaghat
Innovation

 

Alappuzha, Panchgani, Muzaffarpur, Thiruvananthapuram,Mysuru, Balaghat

Source: CSE

Non compliance with SWM Rules

While civic bodies in most forum cities give protecting gear to the casual labourers at various stages of the waste management cycle, additional health assurances were unfulfilled.

“As per SWM Rules, 2016, municipalities need to formalize the informal sector and issue identity cards to them. They should be incentivized to sell dry recyclable waste. Considering their occupational health risks, workers also have to be provided personal protective equipment (PPE) as well as health facilities, including health insurance,” the report points out.

According to the assessment, the informal sector was issued ID cards and the right to sell dry waste in a majority of cities.  “But, cities have done poorly on protecting the health of these workers. PPE has been provided by many cities, but health check-up, health facility and insurance are missing,” the report pointed out.

In summary, while a few Indian cities are slowly taking the path to waste management methods, the fact that a majority of them face hiccups cannot be overlooked. However, waste is everyone’s responsibility, and every individual or organisation has to look inward instead of blaming the civic bodies alone.

The final analysis

Cities have been awarded the green leaves award by CSE based on the percentage of marks obtained in the waste management assessment. To reflect the size of cities and the scale of the Solid Waste Management systems, the assessment has been done separately for cities of different sizes.

The Forum cities were divided into three categories: Cities with a population of more than 1 million, cities with a population between 0.1 – 1.0 million and cities with less than 0.1 million population.

Cities that performed the best were given the five leaves award. The top six cities (five and four leaf award recipients) according to this assessment are as in the table below:

          City   Population       No of leaves 
        Vengurla       <0.1 million           Five
        Indore       >1 million           Four
        Mysuru       >1 million          Four
        Thiruvananthapuram       0.1 – 1million          Four
        Alapuzzha      0.1 – 1 million          Four
         Panchgani      <0.1 million          Four

Source: CSE


1 Comment

  1. Proud to be Mysorian with its effort in all level of waste management and segregation. We from Clean Mysore Foundation are working hard to support our Mysore City Corporation in all levels through public participation. According to the report, we may be bit behind in dry waste management. We definitely put effort further in improving the standards in this area to retain our position on the top.

Comments are closed.